News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by throw16180339 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:50PM (#42131092)
> It's wild how much most people rely on being in an echo chamber. It takes a psychological toll being confronted with opinions that challenge your worldview on a regular basis, especially if you cannot easily dismiss them.

I can easily dismiss antisemitic conspiracy theories, queerphobia, bigotry, and racism. There's an infinite stream of garbage positions, why would would I engage with them?

Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by lend000 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @07:30PM (#42131806)
As I mentioned in a sibling comment, your feed is only toxic insofar you are likely to engage with it. I have never seen a single post on my feed of the vein you are describing.

By the way, there is equally ridiculous garbage on the left, if you go looking for it. You are doing the same thing that every partisan media outlet does, the oldest trick in the book: arguing against a strawman. Just because there is some leftist out there who wants to subsidize transgender operations for illegal immigrants or who wants to cancel anyone who assumes your gender, should I generalize that opinion to you and every left-leaning person on HN?

Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by throw16180339 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:37PM (#42132591)
Elon endorsed antisemitic comments (https://www.politico.eu/article/elon-musk-row-uk-rishi-sunak...) and conspiracy theories. Several studies found that there was a substantial increase in hate speech (https://www.newsguardtech.com/special-reports/twitter-misinf...) after the acquisition. He substantially manipulated opinions on X to serve his own ends, most recently during the election. It's grossly misleading to compare this to a strawman.
Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by lend000 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @10:09PM (#42132759)
I wonder if you can appreciate the irony in your comment.

A news link that does not have any reference to the post in question and you just take their word for their interpretation (I had to google several more articles doing the same thing to try to find the post in question, and gave up), and a "study" that you could not possibly draw any conclusions from in good faith.

This is exactly why X is better now -- there is a free flow of information. Yes, it now leans right if you engage with political posts (whereas it leaned left before, and I suspect you were not complaining). Yes, Elon is autistic and chronically online. And yes, you're far too accustomed to consuming media that does the thinking for you.

Trying to cancel Elon because of political tribalism is the left's biggest mistake. He's literally added more value to this country than every person/organization dramatically quitting X combined. I'm optimistic about what he'll do with a cabinet position w.r.t. America's looming debt crisis (which you probably never think about).

Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by consteval on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:14AM (#42137651)
> your feed is only toxic insofar you are likely to engage with it.

Right, and bigotry raises engagement. This isn't rocket science. Garbage opinions get popular because of how garbage they are. It's the same reason why traffic slows down when there's a car wreck on the other side of the interstate.

Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by southernplaces7 on Friday November 15, 2024 @07:57AM (#42146487)
>Garbage opinions get popular because of how garbage they are

What a neatly convenient and circular argument for completely dismissing anything that gains appeal but you happen to dislike. It must be popular because it's garbage, and couldn't possibly have any parts worth examining.

Re:Why the Guardian is no longer posting on X by consteval on Friday November 15, 2024 @11:03AM (#42148102)
It's just the truth, sorry to be the one to tell you.

The more garbage an opinion is the more outrage it causes. This means more engagement, more comments, more replies, more stitches, more views, more everything. This means creators are incentivized to make this content, and the "algorithms" purposefully promote this content too. Because, objectively, it does very well. Much better than tame or normal content.

It's not just "what I happen to dislike", lol, it's everything. Sure, there's skinheads and such on the right who say blatantly racist or sexist stuff. Some of them are even in Congress (MTG). But on the left, you have those cringe compilations with "blue hair" feminists. I'm a feminist, but I don't agree with those people.

Of course, neither is truly representative of "their side" or, really, anyone. They're just insane wackos. But those opinions garner A LOT of attention, because they're garbage.