News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @03:10PM (#42129426)
At rock bottom a reader needs to make value judgment between several sources. The Coca Cola v Reuters case is absurd but it is absurd in that it should be blatantly obvious to trust a press release less than an investigative publication.

No one said they had to believe everything in the Reuters article. It asked which is more credible.

It’s awful seeing people think themselves into a corner like this.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @03:17PM (#42129511)
It seems like a brand issue for Reuters. The distinction between a press release and investigative journalism is obvious if you know which one is a investigative journalism outlet and which one isn't, but they might just assume Reuters is no different than some other news site that just reprints press releases wholesale in articles (there are legion). They are teens after all, saying something "is from Reuters" might be meaningless to them in the same way "it came over the wire" would be to them.

I wonder if it would be much more stark if you picked Coca Cola vs some well known investigative youtuber. They would probably pick the youtuber much more, I assume.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by notahacker on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @03:37PM (#42129720)
Assuming the source was an aggregator that at worst would simply be reproducing Coca Cola's greenwashing PR was a less reliable source than Coca Cola's greenwashing PR would seem like a pretty bad heuristic...

Granted, there are also conspiracy theory websites likely to be less reliable than Coca Cola about Coca Cola, and activist websites whose reliability on the subject of Coca Cola varies from considerably more to considerably less reliable than Coca Coca's own press team, but I don't see any particular reason why teens would assume Reuters was one of those, even if they didn't know what Reuters was. Particularly not if they were showed the article. Sure, there are other ways you can make it make sense like if you substituted "reliable source of Coca Cola's opinion" into the text. But the more obvious explanation is that a large minority of teenagers believe that the most trustworthy authority on anything about Coca Cola is The Coca Cola Company. Just like similarly large proportions believe that Google's sponsored ads are the most popular or relevant results or that something labelled "Commentary" isn't an opinion...

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @04:22PM (#42130129)
> But the more obvious explanation is that a large minority of teenagers believe that the most trustworthy authority on anything about Coca Cola is The Coca Cola Company.

This would track in the same way with how the very concept of "selling out" doesn't seem like a big thing for young people anymore. Working with any company for money, or parroting what they say, seems to be pretty popular. Influencer roles have made the wholesale commodification of ones life popular, even earnestly desired. That would seem to promote an atmosphere and general sense of going along with whatever a company says in the same way a lifelong employee might feel compelled to "toe the company line".

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mschuster91 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @03:30PM (#42129638)
> The distinction between a press release and investigative journalism is obvious if you know which one is a investigative journalism outlet and which one isn't

Yeah, the thing is that there used to be far less outlets back in the day which you'd come into contact with - you had your local newspaper, radio and TV station and the NYT, WaPo, CNN, MSNBC, Fox or whatever on the national stage. That's it. Anything not on that list at least had some serious money backing it and was thus credible by assumption.

These days, the local news have all gone down the drain and got replaced by an army of bloggers, some with actual blogs, some with Medium/Substack and some just doing shit on Twitter/Instagram. National news got increasingly partisan. And on top of that comes an even larger army of influencers of all kinds - game streamers, sometimes porn models pivoting their career, corporate shills, enemy propagandists...

It's easy for us old guard to at least roughly size the credibility of an outlet. But the young ones? They grew up in a world where the "household names" factually didn't matter.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @04:39PM (#42130291)
But they weren't asking about Reuter or Coca Cola, they were asking about screenshots on a mobile phone, correct?

So they should've made the decision based on the logo in the header?

If they only look at the logo in the header, sure. But if they scanned the whole thing, they would've seen that Coca Cola is claiming to set a goal. Setting a goal is nothing, anyone can do it. There's no point in trying to doubt it.

Reuters on the right is verifying Coca Cola on the left by claiming that Coca Cola indeed set this goal. But they are also making other claims, which make it potentially be false. But Coca Cola here is more credible because:

1. The facts are that Coca Cola is announcing a goal. It's the original source.

2. Reuters is reporting on the original source (potential for error), and then they are making additional claims which may or may not be right. "Coca Cola" being criticized. Who is doing that criticism, yada, yada. Reuters is making much stronger claims that are much more difficult to verify.

Overall Coca Cola's screenshot by any logical measure is more reliable/credible here.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @04:49PM (#42130421)
You are way, way overthinking this. The entire study is multiple results all pointing to kids not understanding how incentives distort content.

> They did better at recognizing Google’s “sponsored” results as ads, but about 40% of teens said they thought it meant those results were popular or of high quality.

Emphasis mine

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:01PM (#42130560)
It's both, these results are paid for, but also they are the ones most likely to receive the clicks aka most popular. Ad Rank = Max CPC Bid x Quality Score. You can pay, but still your ads won't be shown, while if you have good ads they will be clicked most at shown in front most frequently.

They really should word these exercises better.

Here 80% of the kids got it right, because both of those factors influence it. You need both.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:03PM (#42130587)
I suspect you don't spend much time around your average kid, do you?
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:08PM (#42130642)
I am a kid myself however.
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:14PM (#42130718)
Right, and you're completely deluded about what this study is saying.
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:30PM (#42130906)
I think it's making the age old claim every generation makes that "the youth nowadays are ruined".
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:37PM (#42130968)
The correct rebuttal to that claim is not "they say that all the time!" but "the claim is untrue and here is why."

That is what you attempted to do, so credit there, but you failed in that effort because fucking obviously the surveyed teens are not pointing to secondary or tertiary effects of micro-optimizations in ad auctioning algorithms when they say "Sponsored post means more trustworthy content!"

Sometimes bad things do happen. Sometimes things get worse for people. You can't brush it all of by just saying, "well yeah they said bad things were happening before though and actually they're still pretty good."

It totally is worth applying a bit of discount factor due to the effect you're pointing to, but that should not be even close to a 100% discount. The article isn't "making the claim that x," it's showing data.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:50PM (#42131096)
I'll make more arguments:

1. The questions / answer options are flawed and there's multiple interpretations.

2. The study itself looks to have certain biases on what is right or wrong. Binary biases when life and World is much more complex than that.

3. The study based on the structure seems set out to prove the point they wanted to prove.

4. Many teenagers don't even care about the questions/answers or are edgy and will respond however they want without thought. And that's fine, that's normal for teenagers.

5. Countless of unfounded speculative statements based on those metrics.

Here's one more example of the study that seems ridiculous to me:

The highlighted conclusion:

"""More than 8 in 10 teens misjudge strength of U.S. press freedoms, compared with the 2024 Reporters Without Borders ranking"""

The scoring method

---

Notes: Results based on the 1,102 teens who responded to this question. Items may not sum exactly to 100% due to rounding. Rankings of 1-10 were categorized as "much stronger," rankings of 11-44 were categorized as "somewhat stronger," rankings of 45-65 were categorized as "close to/exactly," rankings of 66-100 were categorized as "somewhat weaker" and rankings of 101-180 were categorized as "much weaker." Source: SSRS survey for the News Literacy Project conducted online from May 17 - 28, 2024, with 1,110 teenagers ages 13-18 nationwide.

---

Basically they had to pick US as the 45th to 65th out of all the countries in the World for press freedoms ranking. And if they didn't pick in that range, it's counted as "misjudging". That's ridiculous. Why did they pick this range specifically?

It's ironic to me that this is a study on media literacy.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:54PM (#42131125)
These seem like conclusions you've arrived at, not arguments supporting those conclusions.
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:56PM (#42131143)
Do you think that the statement

"""More than 8 in 10 teens misjudge strength of U.S. press freedoms, compared with the 2024 Reporters Without Borders ranking"""

Is a logical conclusion to categorize you to misjudge the strength if you don't put US in the 45th to 65th position from all the countries in the World?

E.g. you put it as 40th or similar, it means you are "misjudging strength of US press freedoms"? I imagine they don't even know half the countries in the ranking beating US, and even less so would they know how the press is for each and of those countries.

What position would you have guessed yourself?

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @07:08PM (#42131677)
This is a fair critique! I think that's a badly designed question. The questions most people are talking about in this thread, however, are not.
Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:06PM (#42132061)
I get these kind of thoughts about most of the questions there, and starting from the headline picked by fastcompany.

E.g. the first task where they had to ID an ad based on there being certain text such as “WP BrandStudio” and “Content from Safeway.” and then "Only 50%" of teens specified it's an ad. While 30% thought it was opinion, which is a valid and harmless guess to me if you have never heard of those terms. So 80% picked the harmless option in my view.

Next task as well. In my view 86% had the harmless option.

So overall I think depending on the questions you can get very different results, from which you can make very different conclusions.

And based on the overall "vibe" I get from the study it seems like they were set out to prove this and not do a fair study on the topic.

There being a title like "Commentary: Could Taylor Swift be the biggest election influencer of them all?" and the correct answer being an "opinion". It just seems like a "pondering essay" of some sort rather than opinion. I wouldn't call an essay an opinion. I understand that it is labelled as "opinion piece", but I don't see it to be harmful to not be able to label it as such when to me the label intuitively doesn't seem accurate.

Only 12% marked it as news.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by llamaimperative on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:45PM (#42132302)
The distinction between ad and opinion in that example is very strong and extremely clear. The fact that you think it's a blurry distinction is... exactly what the study is arguing.

> And based on the overall "vibe" I get from the study it seems like they were set out to prove this and not do a fair study on the topic.

I would caution against arbitrarily discounting information because you don't like its "vibe." Even if the vibe is off or unfair, it turns out good information can come from unfriendly sources.

Re:Teens learn a new conspiracy theory every week on social ... by mewpmewp2 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @05:08AM (#42134684)
To me ultimately all of these are "labels". It doesn't necessarily matter how you label something. I can tell you with high certainty that when I was a teenager, it wouldn't have made any practical difference whether I thought the piece about "Vegan meat being as good as the real meat" was an ad or it was an opinion. Neither of those would've been "the truth" for me. Even if it it's an ad, it is still an opinion. And if it's an opinion, it could just be opinion from a vegan propagandist. I may have marked it as opinion just because I have no good way to tell for sure that it's paid for, based on that screenshot, unless I know exactly what the terms above mean and I'm familiar with. I assume I wouldn't have been able to Google during the survey. All of these survey questions are about how you label something, while ignoring common sense completely. And you could orchestrate any sorts of metrics results depending on what content you provide and how you form the question. Whether the above is an ad or an opinion, I wouldn't as teen have believed that vegan meat was as good as the real thing unless I've tried it myself.

The label doesn't matter, what matters is what do you start to take as fact or belief based on the content given. The correct question should've been "To what extent does this article change your belief/opinion about vegan meat being as good as the real thing?".

If you want to test the true thing, ask questions where answers to those questions actually matter in implicating certain beliefs, not just how good people are knowing at exact definition of certain labels. That's anti common sense and literacy.

> I would caution against arbitrarily discounting information because you don't like its "vibe."

I mean I looked at the questions and tried to figure out how I would've approached them as a teen, and what I would've answered. I did it on the basis of a skeptical vibe, because of the initial titles and everything was trying to portray a certain narrative which is not very scientific. So then of course I was biased to play devil's advocate, but none the less, I believe that these results don't carry much meaning and the conclusions that are made, is not something that can really be made from this particular data. It would be harmful to consider an AD an actual factual news report, but this is what very few did. Also considering opinion as a factual news report would've been bad, but again only very few did. If you look at harmful vs harmless labelling then the stats don't look that bad at all. Someone considering the piece about elections and Taylor Swift an entertainment instead of opinion. This is pretty harmless.

I do still remember what I was like as a teen, I remember my thought process, and I can still relate to myself at that point.