News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by gorjusborg on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:27AM (#42126351)
So, am I reading this correctly?

Researchers try to get paper published, but publisher asks for paper authors to add citations that weren't used in the research, presumably to increase citations of certain 'blessed' papers.

Authors add the citations, but also a note that the citations were not used and were asked for by the publisher.

If this is all correct, I'm curious what the publisher's relationship is to those cited papers. Were the citations paid for? Something else?

Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by ellisv on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @10:21AM (#42126791)
The publisher operates a peer-reviewed journal. The process is that the author(s) submit a paper to the journal which is briefly evaluated by an editor and then undergoes a review process. Journal editors maintain a list of reviewers comprised of past reviewers, authors, etc. For example, if you are publishing a paper on topic X then the editor will try to assign it to reviewers who are knowledgeable and specialized in topic X.

Papers are usually reviewed by ~3 reviewers who can ask for revisions. Reviewers are typically anonymous to the authors, although the authors are usually not anonymous to the reviewers. If the reviewers ask for revisions (most common), the authors can revise the paper. This can go back and forth numerous times.

Reviewers can be professors, PhD students, etc. and are paid by the journal for their time. There are many ways to manipulate the system. Reviewers can block or slow the publication of a rival, or they can suggest changes that benefit themselves (e.g. quid pro quo). Often this isn't so blatant and the line can be very blurry.

The publisher and editor typically don't care much about the politics and conflicts of interest.

Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by tamcap on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @10:36AM (#42126935)
> Reviewers can be professors, PhD students, etc. and are paid by the journal for their time.

Most journals do not pay for reviewers time. There are some experiments that allow for this, but I would say 99% of the reviews out there are done... "out of the goodness of the reviewer's heart".

There are indirect benefits to being a reviewer, such as early access to unpublished work, "goodwill" with the editor, etc.

Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by tahoupt on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @10:34AM (#42126908)
Reviewers don’t get paid (it’s only the Editor-in-chief, usually, who gets some salary).
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by rcxdude on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @08:06PM (#42132059)
This is often one of the more blatant ways the review process is de-anonymized. If a reviewer comes back saying you need to cite 3 papers all with the same author, they're probably that author, especially if they're only tenuously connected to the paper.
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by tokai on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:29AM (#42126369)
No not the publisher. The reviewers - other researchers.
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by Ekaros on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:33AM (#42126397)
On other hand the editor employed(or at least appointed) by Elsevier did pass on these...
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by tokai on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:43AM (#42126464)
Thats what makes it fun. Reviewer-coerced citations are almost ubiquitous - at least in the mildest forms. But it's rarely admitted like here. I bet many editors never reread papers, and just go by the reviewers word. Bet they were told that the paper is fine for publication with some added citations. The authors added them, editor and reviewers see the citations in the reference list and off it goes to be published.
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by jsiepkes on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @10:21AM (#42126795)
LGTM!
Re:Elsevier may wish they had checked the revision a bit mor... by haccount on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @09:35AM (#42126413)
Trust the science! Is this peer reviewed?

Lmao