Ask HN: Ditching My Laptop for a Desktop
Hey folks,
I'm facing a decision on upgrading my dev machine and considering a switch from laptop to desktop. The price difference is significant - looking at $3k+ for a well-spec'd laptop versus around $1.5k for a comparable desktop.
My thinking: Most of my work is done at a fixed location anyway Git/version control means I can still use my existing laptop as backup for mobile work Getting twice the performance per dollar seems compelling
For those who've made this switch: How has it worked out? Any unexpected issues or benefits? Did the cost savings justify any trade-offs?
(
9 comments
| on HN
)
It makes for a conundrum when you finally need to replace the laptop. It isn't your primary use machine, so it becomes hard to justify costs of upgrading components on a replacement, but you need something that can do the core things your desktop does if you need to work while travelling (or the desktop is out of action).
I like working from a desk. I feel locked in, and when I get up, it really is to take a break from the work
The cost savings are certainly worth it. I also grew up with desktop computing until college, and even then the laptop rarely left my dorm room. So maybe I’m just used to working this way
I recently spec’d out some comparable machines from Apple - $999 gets you a 32GB Mac Mini M4. A comparably setup Macbook Air (24GB, M3) costs $1299, and the current gen Macbook Pro is $1999. That’s a lot more money for a small screen and small keyboard
It's worked out fantastic for me. I've sacrificed nothing and gained a much better machine.
For over a decade, I have preferred an ergonomic chair, lots of deskspace, 3 LCD screens, fullsize keyboard, trackball and a powerful desktop with masses of storage, RAM and performance.
For me peering through the single screen of a laptop and trying to retain context which multiple monitors affords strains my brain. Adding extra screen, etc to a laptop defeats the portability aspect.
When away from the desk, I just use a Chromebook - cheap, secure and runs all day. The idea of being away from the desk is to interact with people, etc. Not bury my head in code development in some noisy cafe.