exactly correct. A city should be a bureaucratic, administrative organization that collects taxes, and funds projects. These projects should be done by professional project doers - such as construction companies, or IT companies, or bakers. There ought to be many project doers, all competing for the city's funding. The city's job is to find the lowest cost, highest value project doer to give them the project.
The people of the city chooses what projects to fund, and the city takes care of the administrative work of allocating the tax dollars. Nowhere in this loop should a city be keeping employees on hand in the expectation of projects that need doing.
Someone wrote an editorial that would not pass HN's comment policy, basically to the effect of "who would ever have guessed that it might snow in between Christmas and New Year?" and sidewalk-clearing went back to being a public task.
No it isn't. What nonsense. Cities have been doing things themselves all around the world for decades because it generally makes more sense.
> Nowhere in this loop should a city be keeping employees on hand in the expectation of projects that need doing.
They already do that, look at just IT for example, they maintain websites, databases, etc. They don't outsource everything, that's ridiculous.
You are severely underestimating how much a company will mark up the cost to make a profit.
> Do you make your own clothes? Certainly it must be cheaper to do it yourself rather than buy a shirt from a company, right?
Poor analogy. The fare system being talked about is a big investment that doesn't need to be replaced every year. A closer equivalent would be building your own computer, and yes many people do. The parts they manufacturer they still buy or have made.
> Repeat ad nauseam.
Except your analogy doesn't apply across the board and you know this. If we extrapolate from your reasoning a city shouldn't do anything themselves.