News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jjk166 on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:40PM (#42110666)
If you managed to prevent the extinction of the the African Bush Elephant, what would you do with it?

Species do not need to exists for a utilitarian purpose. Bringing back something that once existed can be a perfectly justifiable end in itself. Preventing a species from going extinct is not particularly controversial, even reintroducing species that have not been seen in a land in many generations is widely done and celebrated. The only difference between that and reintroducing a species that went extinct globally is the technical difficulty.

It's very reasonable to believe that there could be benefits to restoring ecosystems, and that might motivate some people to provide their effort and resources to the endeavor moreso than the restoration of nature, but it's perfectly fine to have multiple aligned motivations.

The world is a dynamic place, the true exercise in ego is to define the world as it happened to be when you were born into it as the status quo that ought to be maintained.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by parl_match on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:49PM (#42110722)
I think there's a stark difference between an animal that evolved to live in a world that no longer exists, versus an animal that was hunted to extinction, for which there exists a plausible environment in which it can thrive.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by adastra22 on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:03PM (#42110835)
Mammoths were hunted to extinction and would otherwise do just fine in many wild parts of the world.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by derefr on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:33PM (#42112827)
The "mammoth steppe" — the biome that supported mammoths — was a place that was cold (due to a glacial maximum) but bright (due to not being very polar.) Which made for endless fields of nutrient-dense grasses to graze on. Which made for lots of crazy-big grazing animals.

There is no modern-era equivalent to the mammoth steppe. Savanna biomes are too hot (thus, elephants — mammoths adapted for the heat); and tundra biomes don't get enough sun (thus only supporting very small herbivorous tundra animals, with even the apex predators of that food chain not being anything like megafauna.)

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by adastra22 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @02:36AM (#42113534)
That’s just the steppe mammoth. There were other mammoth species that lived in less frigid environments.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by bdhcuidbebe on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @02:42AM (#42113555)
Maybe stick to your day job.

Many megafauna existed outside the steppes. First example that comes to mind is the european forest elephant.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straight-tusked_elephant

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by derefr on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @02:55AM (#42113623)
Okay? I wasn’t trying to make any claim in contravention of what you just said.

My points were these:

1. the steppe mammoth specifically (i.e. the one everyone means when they reference humans hunting mammoths to extinction) existed as it did because of the mammoth steppe’s unique biome;

2. megafauna that were endemic to the mammoth steppe are not transplantable to any biome we have today, because they were adapted specifically to those conditions (thus the being-endemic, rather than ranging elsewhere), and we no longer have those conditions. (They might survive, but they would quickly adapt out of the phenotype we recognize. You’d just get another elephant.)

I made no claim about the survivability of megafauna that did range outside of the steppe. Clearly, if they were out there, they were able to be out there; and we do have equivalent biomes to those today.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by Retric on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:02AM (#42114858)
I’m not sure the distinction you have between mammoth steppe and northwestern US wood bison habitat.

Wood bison are practically identical to steppe bison so the conditions must be very similar. Elephants aren’t cold adapted running into issues well above freezing (~42f), so anyplace that gets midwestern cold like say Mongolia isn’t going to result in them evolving into something roughly equivalent to elephants.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by derefr on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:25PM (#42119357)
The wood bison's range included tundra! I.e. they were hardier than the steppe-endemic megafauna that were killed off by the retreat and vanishing of the steppe, being able to survive (though probably not thrive) on the sort of scrub brush that grows at the taiga-tundra perimeter (which in turn is all that grows there, because of the lack of enough sun-warming for much of the year.)

Note that maps that claim to depict the "mammoth steppe", that you might find when searching, mostly aren't; they are actually usually maps depicting the range of the set of megafauna we associate with the steppe. But many of those megafauna have ranges that exceed the extent of the mammoth-steppe biome — i.e. they're not endemic to the steppe. So these depictions exaggerate the size of the steppe.

For example, these maps show areas within the arctic circle as part of the steppe — but they definitely were not part of the steppe biome. They were tundra then, just as they are now.

If you divide "megafauna you could find on the mammoth steppe" into "endemic to the steppe" vs "ranged to other biomes, such as tundra", I'm not sure what the precise ratio of the two groups would be; but AFAIK, the species that vanished along with the steppe (mostly not from human predation!) constituted at least a majority of such megafauna.

Which should be obvious — we'd have a lot more megafauna otherwise!

Also,

> Wood bison are practically identical to steppe bison so the conditions must be very similar.

This is an argument from phenotype, and that really doesn't work.

Species that happen to present identically when put into the same habitat, are just doing (over the course of a generation or two) the epigenetic equivalent of convergent evolution — flipping all the methylation switches to activate similar developmental strategies that they both happen to have evolved at some point in the past, either independently or in some common ancestor. (In the case of the wood and steppe bison, that would be the "it's cold, but there's lots of food; so I should get big, get strong enough to defend myself, grow lots of heavy fur, and minimize surface area per volume" strategy.)

But if you take two such "phenotypically identical" species out of the same habitat, and place them into a different habitat, they may have wildly different responses to that adaptive pressure. One species may not have the adaptations the other does, and so one species may do well while the other fails to thrive. Or the two species may have very different adaptations, such that they end up inhabiting different ecological niches in their new habitat, when previously they fit into the same slot.

Which is to say: steppe bison died out (long before the sort of en masse human predation that drove the plains bison to extinction), but wood bison survived. There's probably some good reason for that. (I'm not a zoologist, but I would hazard a guess that it has something to do with the wood bison also being known as the mountain bison — i.e. with their ability to range beyond flat plains/steppe!)

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by Retric on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:43PM (#42121269)
> Species that happen to present identically when put into the same habitat,

Your argument suggested that these are very different environments. “You’d just get another elephant.”

If convergent evolution is pushing the same adaptations then that suggests something already evolved to exist in a similar environment would be reasonably stable especially across human timescales. Kansas gets cold but it’s hardly the Arctic Tundra.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:17PM (#42120377)
> 1. the steppe mammoth specifically (i.e. the one everyone means when they reference humans hunting mammoths to extinction)

The steppe mammoth became extinct 200,000 years ago, it likely never encountered homo sapiens. The name is also a bit of a misnomer - they were associated with the steppe but were not confined to them.

When people talk about mammoths hunted to extinction by humans, they are usually referring to the woolly mammoth, which had a much wider range. They've been found from southern Spain to Kentucky. They might also be talking about the Columbian mammoth which resided in lower latitude parts of North America as far south as Costa Rica. Both the woolly and columbian mammoths are descended from the steppe mammoth, and both went extinct at the end of the Pleistocene with pygmy populations surviving on islands into the Holocene. Both survived numerous previous interglacial periods.

The "mammoth steppe" is just a poetic name for a biome common at the time, indeed the most common biome on Earth during the age of the woolly mammoth, it's not actually a term for a region the woolly mammoth was endemic to. It is by definition distinct from currently existing steppe climates, but the differences are mostly academic and does not explain the extinction of the mammoths. Indeed it is believed that the decline of the steppe was likely caused by the extinction of the mammoth (and other large herbivores), as they prevented trees from becoming too large or numerous, and in their absence much of the steppe turned into forest.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by nostrebored on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:51PM (#42110737)
The idea that ecosystems haven't been in permanent flux forever is odd.

Things have been going extinct for millennia with no human intervention. The idea of the butterfly effect from human intervention causing ecosystem collapse is filled with hubris. There are some things that will obviously change a landscape. If we were to completely deforest the Amazon then there could be some disastrous consequences, sure.

But the Brazilian Three Eyed Skunkowl going extinct isn't likely to cause some devastating collapse outside of a poorly-done model.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by griffzhowl on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:07PM (#42110857)
Of course things have always been changing, but the current rate of extinction hasn't been equalled since the four or five largest mass extinction events. It's not an ordinary situation in life's history. Ultimately it depends what you care about but it's inarguable that the natural world is being greatly impoverished in ways that could take millions of years to recover from (e.g. in terms of species numbers)
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by ANewFormation on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:55PM (#42111522)
I think one nuance that empasizes his point is that within millions of years, and likely much sooner (as we are already rather 'overdue'), there will almost certainly be another genuine mass extinction event that will once again strip most life from this planet.

The notion of rates is also quite a bit more contentious than many appreciate. The extremely high rates in modern times are based on modeling with rather debated assumptions. This is how you get claims of hundreds of extinctions per day even though there have only been about 800 'verified' extinctions in the past 400 years [1]. And, notably, a number of those verified extinct species ended up showing up elsewhere later on!

[1] - https://e360.yale.edu/features/global_extinction_rates_why_d...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by nostrebored on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:35PM (#42111754)
This is exactly what confuses me -- we're modeling both the inputs and outputs, and not with particularly robust validation or verification.

Where is the utility?

We've established that things are changing. Sure. But if you gave someone a 'stock predictor' of similar quality, few people would choose to trust it with money. But in reality, we dedicate billions of dollars of resources collectively to the outputs of biome modeling.