Does freedom of speech mean everyone should be able to demand access to a printing press?
Specifically: This marks a departure from the conclusions of the 2nd World Water Forum in The Hague in 2000, which stated that water was a commodity to be bought and sold, not a right.[102] There are calls from many NGOs and politicians to enshrine access to water as a binding human right, and not as a commodity.
It seems to imply pretty clearly that access to water as a human right contradicts requirement for payment. The same argument is frequently heard when the healthcare is discussed. So I would say implying that it means not only ability to access but actually ability to access for all, regardless of means - is not out of the question. At least it does not contradict how many other "rights" are interpreted.
Nah, that's freedom of the press. :P
(Aaand thinking about it, half the people who see this comment won't realize this, so:
That was a joke.)
You seem to be asking this rhetorically, but I don't see what your objection to people being allowed to demand access to the Internet is. Could you actually spell it out?
The Internet just seems really specific (see the list of others at http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/).
That's why people who campaign for positive rights make a grave error, IMO. It cheapens the entire concept.
That's roughly what taxes are for, yes.
> Why is the Internet a human right but electricity, which is kind of critical to running the Internet, is not?
There are a number of arguments for electricity being a human right. I'm perfectly okay with saying it is one.
That said, the interesting point is that you're imagining electricity here to be an implicit right of Internet access. That's fine, but it implies that, if Internet access did not require electricity (and who knows, maybe it won't someday), the claim is that Internet access remains a human right without a need to imply a right to electricity.
Freedom to access internet is to same level, it means human people shouldn't be arbitrarily blocked from accessing internet, that's all, that's enough, and that's already a lot, actually.
I'm okay with those who have having to pay for those who have not.
The purpose of the law is to make sure, that those bubbles are about equally sized for everyone.
Rights are "not absolute" only is the sense that exercising your right does not absolve you from responsibility for violating other people's rights. So, if you exercise your right to freely use your property, say, a gun, and shoot somebody - you'll go to jail. But not for using your gun - but rather for violating other's right to live unshot by your gun. Your right to use your property didn't go anywhere, but it also didn't remove your responsibility for the consequences of such use. If there's no consequences, there's no place for government to intervene (I know most governments disagree, of course they do).
This seems to be the most natural definition of rights. I can say whatever unless doing so prevents you from also speaking. Thus, I can't use even larger speakers to drown out what a protesters outside my factory are saying. But, I could use them to convey my message.
[1]https://www.btg-bestellservice.de/pdf/80201000.pdf - see Article 5
Second, "freedom" is not a right and never has been. It is not a useful term on its own. You can be free to do something, or free from something, but you can't just be generically free.
I think the Internet absolutely should receive First Amendment protection in the US (and the US Supreme Court agrees), but calling it a human right doesn't seem to agree with the definition[2]. I'd love to hear arguments for the other side.
Note that this doesn't mean I think governments should be able to actively deny individuals access to the Internet, but a Constitutional right is not the same as a human right.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Lamprecht
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights