News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by tikhonj on Friday July 06, 2012 @05:23PM (#4209717)
No it isn't. The point isn't that you should get free internet--the point is that a government should not prevent you from freely using the internet. This is no different from a right to, say, travel.

The internet is particularly important because it is very good for getting a message out to the world at large. Other existing channels tend to be more difficult to use or more limited. The internet lets people document current events first-hand without having to rely on reporters or news organizations.

So there are definitely some completely rational and practical reasons to declare internet access an international right, at the very least as a check against oppressive government.

Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by kevinpet on Friday July 06, 2012 @07:25PM (#4210068)
That's not what someone means when they say "every child has a right to an education". They do not mean "the government cannot prevent you from getting an education". They mean "the government must provide you with an education".

No one has a right to travel. It's actually phrased as the right to freedom of movement, which is a good confusing phrase because it prevents you from thinking you already know what it means. You have (in a free country) the right to go where you want. You don't have the right to a plane ticket.

Positive rights are dangerous. Positive rights inherently impose obligations on someone. They should be phrased that way to begin with. I can rationally discuss the idea of "education is an obligation of government" because it means what it says. If I dare say "children don't have a right to an education" I'll get lynched.

Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by sophacles on Friday July 06, 2012 @08:16PM (#4210221)
Your choice of an example is rather poor, as you now are conflating issues of children's rights with something else. Saying children have a right to an education only means we have to pay for them, because they regularly can't pay for themselves through no fault of their own - this is a different issue than what the right entails.

For many many many examples of how your argument breaks down, look no further than the US constitution. We have the right to freedom of the press - yet no one demands they get a free press. The right to bear arms - yet no one demands the government give everyone guns to exercise that right. The right not be compelled to self-incriminate, yet no one demands free paper shredders or disk wiping utilities. The right to sue anyone for more than $25, but no one demands free lawyers (for this purpose criminal defense is a different -- no disingenuous replies on this please).

So yeah a positive right in this case would provide an obligation for someone, but it doesn't mean providers must give no-charge options, it means the government would be obliged to not deny citizens internet access (except possibly as a penalty for crimes, ala prison does for a lot of rights).

Essentially this is a longwinded way of me stating this is a combination of strawman and slippery slope fallacies piled on factually incorrect statements.

Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by baddox on Friday July 06, 2012 @08:04PM (#4210184)
Another example is "the right to health care." People don't use that to mean that you have the right to pay thousands of dollars for an MRI. They generally mean the government should provide health care.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by gsmaverick on Friday July 06, 2012 @08:47PM (#4210304)
Well then they are using the word `right` incorrectly.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by ams6110 on Friday July 06, 2012 @09:38PM (#4210404)
Yeah the word to use is 'entitlement' which is very different from a 'right'
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by sbov on Saturday July 07, 2012 @07:28AM (#4211392)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rights disagrees with you. So does dictionary.com. Got a better reference for me?
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by saraid216 on Friday July 06, 2012 @07:36PM (#4210098)
I'm okay with saying that it's an obligation.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by spindritf on Friday July 06, 2012 @06:13PM (#4209885)
> The point isn't that you should get free internet--the point is that a government should not prevent you from freely using the internet.

Isn't that already covered under freedom of speech?

Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by roryokane on Friday July 06, 2012 @07:39PM (#4210108)
I don’t think so. With only freedom of speech, the government could still ban access to all foreign-country-hosted read-only sites – sites without commenting or other interactivity. That would include many informational sites and blogs.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by SoftwareMaven on Friday July 06, 2012 @07:52PM (#4210145)
And does this prevent that? China and Iran signed on as well.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by _delirium on Friday July 06, 2012 @08:03PM (#4210180)
In practice, no, because UN resolutions are only as good as their ability to enforce them, which in the case of general-assembly resolutions basically boils down to no ability, except attempting to shame people who flaunt them. Only a handful of UN organs (e.g. the Security Council and the International Criminal Court) have anything approaching teeth.
Re:Internet Access Is a Human Right, Says United Nations by saraid216 on Friday July 06, 2012 @09:45PM (#4210422)
One of the problems of "freedom of speech" is that many people have bundled a lot of concepts into "speech". There are a great many Internet activities that would be difficult to capture as speech.

Reading a political screed, for instance, is not speech. It is probably protected in some other way, but I'm actually unaware of how. (Actually, considering workplace laws, I begin to suspect it's not protected.) Differently, is clicking a Like button considered speech? What about Unliking? How about transferring a file, or maintaining a personal wiki that no one else has access to?

These aren't questions I want answered anytime soon. I'd rather leave them alone and simply say that people should have the opportunity to engage in these activities, full stop, without having to figure out whether or not they're speech.