Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by aaronblohowiak on Monday January 05, 2009 @07:41PM
(#421394)
Bob killed.
killed has a conotation, but it's still something he did not something he is.
Bob killed, in self defense. vs Bob killed, ted as part of a murderous rampage. Or even.
Bob stood hatchet in hand over the chicken and hesitated.
Bob Killed.
Where Bob is a killer becomes harder to place into an interesting story.
Re:English-Prime - English without "is"
by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday January 06, 2009 @02:25PM
(#422315)
Ah. Then to fit in E-Prime, I believe you'd have to state what Bob was doing as a killer.
The killer Bob <verb:[lived sat stood munched ...]>.
Separating what is happening from what why it happened is why mystery's work. Using "is" allows writers to easily classify things, where showing what is happening is far more interesting.
The more you need to think about what your writing the better. vs. I find it increases clarity when I carefully examine my words before writing them down.