As a graduate student at Berkeley, I had my own room in an apartment with a roof deck and uninterrupted bay view for $400/mo on a month-to-month lease in a great neighborhood. This was 6 years ago, but the same guy was still subletting the same rooms for the same price, when last I spoke to him.
When I moved to the peninsula to work at Apple, I had a small house with a yard and fruit trees in the nice part of Menlo Park on a month-to-month lease for $1000/mo. This was 4 years ago, but similar deals can definitely still be found (the same house was rented for $1300/mo recently).
Up to a year ago, my wife and I shared a lovely house with 1.5 acres in Palo Alto for $1800/mo, though we did need to sign a lease for that one.
When I travel back to the bay area now, I get an airbnb-type room in Palo Alto, and don't typically pay more than $800/mo short-term. A lot of things are listed at higher rates, but you can often negotiate pretty successfully. It certainly doesn't hurt to ask.
The ridiculous rents that you hear about in the bay area are partially due to a genuine real estate crunch, but they are largely also due to people having too much money and not enough sense. Paying $1200/mo for a dorm is nuts, no matter what city it's in.
Having lived in SV all my life, these "Hacker Hostels" just seem like a way for the operators to exploit those who flock to their services, who just don't know any better.
No problem if they stay there for a couple weeks, up to a month, while getting situated or doing a bunch of meetings, but living there for months shows lack of judgement. You can get a hotel in Santa Clara- rack rate- for $50, and a nice one at that.
This is like asking the success rate of an actor/actress in LA versus in other cities.
One of the major benefits that's routinely touted is access to VC/angel. Something that most people forget is that the odds of getting such investment are relatively small and most start-ups thrive without it.
If you want to increase your likelihood to get funding, you have to be here in the Bay Area.
I'm not sure why charging people is considered to be a shocking idea. A business is supposed to charge people, or find another way to make money, such as smothering eyeballs with advertising. I'd rather have a profitable company that has positive cash flow and a sustainable growth rate than a "big" company with a ton of freeloaders and external investment.
If you're going to cite Twitter and Facebook as an example, the odds of you creating a similar company are akin to finding Willy Wonka's golden ticket.
VC just isn't available or necessary in the vast majority of cases, negating the need to be in the Bay Area. Bear in mind that VCs are all over the place, from Boston to New York to London. The benefit you cited elsewhere that it's fun to be in the Bay Area is, however, the most compelling.
The only true blue benefit I can see to even being in the US is access to better payment solutions, and possibly a culture that better supports brazen entrepreneurialism.
[1] http://www.quora.com/Venture-Capital/What-are-the-odds-of-ge...
A few thoughts. One obviously is taking the social proof of what others are doing and copying it.
The other is that "if you don't have anything good to say, don't say anything at all". So having revenue of $0 is better than having revenue of $15000 (2nd number arbitrary just trying to illustrate that by showing a number you are likely to be judged differently then if you never charged at all and can point to eyeballs or signups and have the focus on that).
Most people I know doing startups especially in the Bay Area want that golden ticket. Odds are very low but that's what people aspire for.
Taking it to basketball analogy.
There are millions of basketball players out there and all of them aspire to one day play in the NBA. Chances are slim since there are only about 450 players in the NBA in a given season.
But you are pitching more than 1 VC.
Rose said "VCs invest in roughly 1 out of 400 companies who pitch them." and it's obvious he means "an individual VC".
Most importantly (something I try to point out with respect to dating as well or anything where success is essentially "1") you are looking for 1 person/firm to believe in you.
There are exceptions, but that's the general model and people have made billions with it so arguing against it is an uphill battle.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B008035HQQ/ref=as_li_ss_tl?...
It does look like an interesting book though and I'll grab a copy.
Lest we forget, the old way of charging for something still works. In fact, with the internet, it's extremely easy to reach a huge international audience. Customers don't give one shit where you live.
If you are trying to get a lot of big investors for your social platform that has to explode, sure, SF/SV is probably the absolute best for that, but you can start a business anywhere.
>> $1,200/month or less gets you your own private room in a shared apartment in NYC, Boston
In much of the US, $1,200/mo will buy you a house (or rent one). $1,200/mo is a fairly high rent for a 1-bedroom in much of the US; a private room in a shared apartment would obviously be correspondingly less.