News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by munin on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:45PM (#4205825)
how would open source software prevent this?

I have an open source Buffalo router that shipped with DD-WRT. it has a service onboard where I can run an alternate SSID as a free wifi hotspot, and software on the router will inject a frame into clients web browsers to serve ads.

evil? yep. on by default? no. implemented entirely with open source software? yes.

what would happen if this feature shipped in an open-source router on-by-default and without the software button to click to change it? are you seriously advocating to consumers that they download the source code to their router, change some #defines to remove the code that injects ads, recompile it, and reload it onto their router?

Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by DougBTX on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:51PM (#4205846)
The argument is that downloading a compiled version of the software patched in that way is something that people would be willing to do to remove ads, but that re-implementing the software from scratch just to remove ads is not something that anyone would do.
Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by wpietri on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:49PM (#4205838)
Why would most consumers need to do that? It only takes one HNish person to get the code, fix it, and release something that consumers can easily use.
Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by munin on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:53PM (#4205853)
reflashing router firmware is still something out of reach to most consumers. it would probably not even occur to most consumers that the ads in their web browser would be something they could change.
Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by jiggy2011 on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:56PM (#4206149)
You could ask/pay/sleep with a person of your choosing and have them do it for you.

To the second point, if you had a world with mostly open source software then people would start to assume that things like that could be done.

It's like arguing that you should design cars to be only serviceable by the manufacturer simply because not everyone is a mechanic.

Re:ESR: Cisco provides a lesson by derleth on Thursday July 05, 2012 @09:15PM (#4205901)
> reflashing router firmware is still something out of reach to most consumers

I don't know. I'm always amazed at what a few good blog posts can do if enough people see them.