News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by nchlswu on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:43PM (#4204628)
I don't see Apple being one to release the tablet just to compete. The 7" would eat into 10" sales and a new formfactor only adds another resolution that devs have to account for (unless the original iPad's resolution is effectively retina at a 7" size?).

When it comes to portability, would 7" be that much more portable? I know people can put these in their pockets, but it's hardly practical.

Ultimately, it doesn't quite make sense to me at this moment. In the event that Apple does release a 7" one day, I really think there'd have to be a drastic repositioning of the 10" or the 7" would serve some special niche purpose

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by arn on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:47PM (#4204643)
Part of the point of the article is that it would not really add another resolution that devs would have to account for.

A 7.85" iPad could have the exact same resolution as a non-retina 9.7" iPad and still have the same pixel density as the iPhone. This would result in UI elements that would be no smaller than normal for the iPhone, making it relatively easy for existing iPad apps to run with no modification.

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by nchlswu on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:09PM (#4204730)
The article focused on resolution, but with all of Apple's flagship mobile offerings bearing retina displays, I consider it a requirement that any new device is retina.

I didn't make it clear, but I understand the author's talking about logical resolution. I'm wondering if the iPad (1024x768) resolution scaled to 7" would effectively be Retina based on Apple's definitions. He scaled it by a factor of the iPhone's logical PPI (not the Retina pixel density). If the resolution was scaled by the required PPI to create a retina display (at ~7"), would a 1024x768 display still work out to a physical size of approximately 7"?

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by telcodud on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:06PM (#4204724)
Can you walk us through the math you did to arrive at the following conclusion?

A 7.85" iPad could have the exact same resolution as a non-retina 9.7" iPad and still have the same pixel density as the iPhone.

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by arn on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:15PM (#4204749)
So the trick is that Apple tells App devs that the minimal tappable UI element at 44x44 points.

- The original iPhone had a PPI of 163PPI

- The original iPad had a PPI of 132PPI

The 44x44 point recommendation was the same for the iPhone and iPad. So the minimal tappable element on the iPad happened to be physically bigger even though it was the same # of points.

A 7.85" iPad happens to have a PPI of 163PPI. (same as original iPhone)

So that means any UI element designed with a minimum of 44x44 points will still be as tappable on a 7.85" iPad as it was on the iPhone. If you see the PDF/actual-size file I linked in another comment, you'll see the UI elements on a 7.85" iPad are no smaller than elements on an iPhone.

actual math here: http://www.appadvice.com/appnn/2012/03/apple-has-163-reasons...

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by protomyth on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:56PM (#4204678)
It would fit the pattern of the iPod if Apple started moving into the lower dollar ranges with new products. Since the article demonstrates that most apps will be fine, it seems like a reasonable win. The retina display is nice in the iPad 3rd generation, so they have a clear differentiator between models besides size.
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by nchlswu on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:34PM (#4204838)
Ah. I never considered the parallels between the iPod device line.

That's probably the one argument that helps me understand and appreciate the reasoning for the 7" a bit more. However, I still consider the retina display a mandatory for all new* products that Apple releases

*where new is not a new revision of an existing device + form factor.

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by protomyth on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:47PM (#4204878)
I get the feeling the normal displays are going to hang around for a while. Keeping a non-retina iPhone model (3GS successor) would allow Apple to continue its move into prepay with a cheaper device than the retina iPhones.
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by geon on Thursday July 05, 2012 @05:48PM (#4205157)
I have thought about this too, but how it would work for the iPhone product line. What would an iPhone nano or iPhone shuffle look like? Wold there be a market for it?

Obviously, an iPhone "shuffle" would not randomly call people, but could perhaps be displayless. Even voice-only controlled.

Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by protomyth on Thursday July 05, 2012 @06:00PM (#4205213)
For a while, retina versus non-retina displays, lower spec camera, less storage, and different case (new vs classical).
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by geon on Friday July 06, 2012 @03:25AM (#4206746)
No. Compare the iPod touch, to the iPod nano or shuffle. it's a completely diffrent form factor, not just a lower resolution screen.
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by protomyth on Friday July 06, 2012 @08:18AM (#4207414)
The principle is to have a range of models, changes to form factor aren't really that easy on a device that developers have to target. That is why I believe the differences will not be form factor based.
Re:The case for a 7.8” iPad by geon on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:43PM (#4212505)
Well, AFAIK, you can't develop third party apps for the ipod shuffle/nano. An iPhone shuffle/nano would not be a smartphone.