Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by saurik on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:01PM
(#4204117)
One complexity is that it has been ruled that your cell phone is not a container that protects its contents, so police are allowed to search it without a warrant. This is not true, however, if it is in a physical locked container such as your glove compartment (where it is much less likely to be able to hear anything).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by tuxidomasx on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:16PM
(#4204189)
Its probably possible to send the recordings TO a unit inside a locked container in your car (via wifi).
I know this might limit the use-cases for an app, as well as require more effort to do, but that would be pretty slick.
Another way to protect the recordings is to live stream the audio to the internet (with location info). This way, the data is already stored online before the police have a chance to go poking around in a confiscated phone.
Maybe even make the streams available in real-time so people can listen in on live stops as they happen.
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by saurik on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:23PM
(#4204530)
To be clear, I was bringing up this concern not to protect the recordings (although I do agree that is an interesting point, albeit one easily solved by the "stream it to the Internet" mechanism), but to point out a practical issue with using your cell phone as the recorder: your cell phone probably has a lot of other things on it, from call histories to SMS logs to photographs, any of which you might not want a police officer randomly digging through "on a whim"; hence the advice people offer to keep it locked in a glove compartment in these situations.
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by stox on Thursday July 05, 2012 @06:33PM
(#4205339)
Android ICS has an option to encrypt the entire device.
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by sigkill on Friday July 06, 2012 @06:23AM
(#4207149)
But are you not required to give the password then?
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by DannyBee on Friday July 06, 2012 @10:31AM
(#4207856)
In the US, this depends on the state/jurisdiction you are in.
It's certainly not the case that cell phone is/is not a container rulings are consistent across the country
Re:ACLU launches phone app to help motorists secretly record...
by einhverfr on Saturday July 07, 2012 @03:39AM
(#4211041)
Beat me to it. Orin Kerr at the Volokh Conspiracy has tended to cover a lot of these cases going both ways.
I am not even sure how many jurisdictions have clear case law on the subject yet.