News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by chipdart on Monday November 04, 2024 @02:31AM (#42039368)
> Managers who are the sort of people who don't value helping your colleagues or being curious/concerned enough about potential security problems, are most likely the sort of people who won't pick up on any of that being a valuable use of your time during one on ones or in standups either.

This is not a "sort of people" problem. This is a metrics problem.

It's not only developers who are evaluated by using useless metrics that don't track the value you add to an organization. Low-level managers are too.

Low-level managers need to evaluate the people assigned to them, they need to evaluate them objectively, and they need to give an unbiased and objectively verifiable score. This means something they can measure, such as metrics or verifiable goals.

If low-level managers cannot do this, they will need to answer why they gave X and Y this score whereas poor little Z who outworked them both was scored lower. Not being able to objectively justify a score is a problem that no manager wants to have, as this is a major liability.

Hence the bullshit metrics and absurd goals. They need something on paper to back up their decisions. A manager might be fully aware that you unblocked half your team members throughout the year with critical help, and that you are the go-to guy to solve critical issues. But if your team members close twice the tickets you did, they will have trouble justifying you are contributing as much as them.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by gradstudent on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:30AM (#42039641)
> But if your team members close twice the tickets you did, they will have trouble justifying you are contributing as much as them.

The metrics make reporting to higher ups easier, no doubt. But the situation you describe is a classic sign of a shit manager: one who cannot justify their decisions except via reference to made up metrics.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Arainach on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:22AM (#42039878)
Unfortunately, a lot of things boil down to metrics, even at companies with great engineering cultures.

If you have four L4 engineers on the team, all of whom are performing at the level described in the career profile as L5, but only budget to promote two of them, how do you pick which two? What if they have different managers, all of whom sincerely believe their report is the one delivering essential value?

If you have an organization with forced bucketing where X% of your team need to be given a subpar rating, how do you decide which one? If you don't have an obvious low performer you'd better have metrics.

This system is soul crushing but it exists all over the industry.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by alextingle on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:38AM (#42039954)
> If you have an organization with forced bucketing where X% of your team need to be given a subpar rating, how do you decide which one?

Easy. You quit, and find a better job.

That practice is so toxic that it's sufficient to condemn the organisation as unworthy of any buy-in whatsoever. Just leave.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by jart on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:14AM (#42042264)
Nah you make sure X% of your team is staffed with losers. It's a nutty system I know. But I'd imagine that's how things worked at companies that have stack ratings. Managers probably traded low performers like baseball cards.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by ethbr1 on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:54AM (#42043437)
In defense of stack ranking, it does solve a very common problem -- managers who never fire people who deserve to be let go.

This ultimately rots an organization from the inside, as it leads to attrition of higher performers because they're forced to work with useless people.

You see this a lot in companies that rarely fire people, because managers optimize for accumulating direct report count (whether or not those direct reports are doing valuable work).

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by convolvatron on Monday November 04, 2024 @12:14PM (#42043689)
companies need to do much better about letting managers go. I get it, they are hard to find. and those that actually have any engineering management skill at all are even harder to find. and every time you hire a new one you're taking a risk that they'll be a absolutely terrible manager. a terrible manager can cause a huge swath of destruction.

but the answer can't be an army of useless middle managers diluting the impact of the people who actually do want to help the company and providing cover for people like them that are just phoning it it.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by ethbr1 on Monday November 04, 2024 @02:43PM (#42045318)
Absolutely. I'd like to see companies get more serious about driving manager requirement from span of control.

As well as regularly rotating managers, like the military does (e.g. 3 year reassignment).

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by marcosdumay on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:13PM (#42046549)
> This ultimately rots an organization from the inside

Hum... So instead you decide to immediately rot the organization from the inside.

I can see how it avoids that one problem. The important problem is the waiting, right?

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by ethbr1 on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:20PM (#42048580)
Try working for IT in a utility, insurance company, or other stable business. You'd be amazed how high the bar for termination is.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by marcosdumay on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @09:34AM (#42051731)
No disagreement here. But you are falling for a very bad logical fallacy.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by gradstudent on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:45AM (#42039995)
> how do you pick which two?

You (=hypothetical manager, please excuse second-person tense) use your managerial skills to make a decision, which considers metrics and other contributing factors. Then you write a justification which you defend, to higher ups and to those who weren't promoted. Because that's your job.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by eesmith on Monday November 04, 2024 @06:37AM (#42040615)
Yes, the Nuremberg defense - "I was just following orders" - is one approach.

It's a lot easier than applying back pressure, fighting for your reports, or quitting in solidarity.

"Sorry, Hugo and Maryna, you two only got the Fields medal while Anton and Alain got a Nobel Prize, so we'll have to let you go for your under-performance."

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Arainach on Monday November 04, 2024 @01:21PM (#42044488)
Here's how this works in practice:

* Corporate says "here are the buckets. They should match at the VP level since that's a large pile of people"

* VPs tell their Directors to match these buckets, who recurse further

* L1/2 Manager Alice says "my team is too small, this isn't how statistics work, I want an exception"

    * Problem #1: the teams with actual low performers will often make similar claims
* If the claim actually gets escalated all the way to the VP, the VP says "tough, fit the buckets".

* Alice is now a troublemaker in VP/Director's eyes

* If Alice and everyone who feels the same way quits in protest, nothing changes except that the org is full of yes men, none of whom are even trying to push for changes in the system any more.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by eesmith on Monday November 04, 2024 @01:53PM (#42044839)
So it's better that Alice stays because ... why?
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Arainach on Monday November 04, 2024 @02:14PM (#42045025)
Because Alice is a good manager who cares about their reports and is otherwise supporting them, advocating for them, pushing for changes to team culture, etc.?

The fact that they can't control this one thing does not mean that they should just abandon the whole company. If Alice finds a company where they can get similar compensation for similar workload without the forced bucketing, perhaps that's a good idea for their mental health, but Alice leaving is a large negative for the team.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by eesmith on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:15PM (#42046561)
I wrote 'applying back pressure, fighting for your reports, or quitting in solidarity'. Alice leaving was the third of these.

'advocating for them' and 'pushing for changes' are parts of the first two.

When back pressure and fighting for your reports does not work, what do you do then?

As you wrote it, Alice leaving is a large negative for the company to, making it full of yes men, unable to change away from a collision course.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Arainach on Monday November 04, 2024 @08:23PM (#42047798)
>When back pressure and fighting for your reports does not work, what do you do then?

Continue fighting the battles you can win. Do your job and do it well. Changing jobs is hard, stressful, unavailable to many people for a variety of reasons, and not guaranteed to improve things. Particularly once you start becoming senior and in management.

If I left a job every time I was faced with a bad situation I would never built up the soft skills or connections to be any good at any connection. Particularly as a first-level manager, where 80% of your job is delivering messages you had no say in but have to own anyway.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by eesmith on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @01:40AM (#42049127)
The comment I replied to at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42039995 was only about following orders, with zero mention of fighting any sort of battle.

My response was meant to be interpreted as doing something other than appeasement, which includes "fighting the battles you can win."

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by marcosdumay on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:12PM (#42046537)
Nah, it's better on the long term if she goes work somewhere better.

But changing jobs doesn't happen immediately, and "somewhere better" may be very hard to find.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by jjav on Monday November 04, 2024 @08:53AM (#42041521)
> Then you write a justification which you defend, to higher ups and to those who weren't promoted.

What happens next is this manager gets a low performance rating themselves, for making decisions not backed by metrics. So next year they conform.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by ryandrake on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:43AM (#42043306)
This "don't make a decision unless it is 100% derived from metrics" mentality I just don't get. A robot could do that. Why is your company out there trying to hire/promote smart managers with good judgment if they don't let those managers apply their brains and judgment? "If employee's measured results > threshold, then reward employee" can be done by a computer. No need for a human manager.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by marcosdumay on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:09PM (#42046503)
People create process because of the principal agent problem.

The upper managers do that because they think the lower ones are lying or incompetent. A traceable process doesn't lie.

And yeah, it's stupid, and it makes the problem worse. It's the reason nonetheless.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by jjav on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @10:26PM (#42057054)
> And yeah, it's stupid, and it makes the problem worse. It's the reason nonetheless.

While that's true, it's also a difficult problem to solve. In tiny organizations like startups where the CEO personally knows everyone and what they do, it's easy.

But as soon as you grow beyond that (and I've been in a number of startups that cross that gap), how do you objectively but fairly handle this? There is no easy answer.

You could go with fully empowering all managers to do as they wish. Trust them to hire, fire and promote correctly. This is great, until you hire some bad managers. And as you grow, it is 100% guaranteed at some point you'll hire bad managers. So then they ruin it for everyone, hiring and promoting their buddies.

And that's how you end up with more objective metrics. Take away some of that freedom, make everyone measure and justify actions based on metrics. It's terrible, but probably better than the alternative.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by kaashif on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:56AM (#42040046)
> If you have an organization with forced bucketing where X% of your team need to be given a subpar rating, how do you decide which one? If you don't have an obvious low performer you'd better have metrics.

This is a case where you're forced to rate people who are up to par as subpar - the rating system is simply bullshit. You should be allowed to rate people according to their actual performance.

Metrics don't solve the underlying problem which is that the rating system sucks. Having a random number generator called "metrics" to "make decisions" isn't good either.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by BeFlatXIII on Monday November 04, 2024 @07:05AM (#42040770)
Dice.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by red_admiral on Monday November 04, 2024 @08:55AM (#42041537)
> If you have an organization with forced bucketing where X% of your team need to be given a subpar rating, how do you decide which one?

I think it's Joel Spolsky who has a tale of a manager asking him to do that for his team when everyone had gone all in with overtime to get something shipped on time. To their great credit, the author refused, and the manager saw sense.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Yizahi on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:20AM (#42041737)
Pfff, what kind of problem question is that. Manager promotes the ones who go with him for a smoke or do some other regular informal activity together, obviously. :)
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by csa on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:43AM (#42041932)
> If you have an organization with forced bucketing where X% of your team need to be given a subpar rating, how do you decide which one? If you don't have an obvious low performer you'd better have metrics.

If you’re a manager in this type of system, your job is to reach out constantly and find folks who are low performers and get them into your department. They will fill the bottom of your team rating chart. At that point, they can be managed out (ideally in a humane way) or just held onto to fill that cellar dweller role while not slowing others down (some people are ok with this as long as they get paid).

I would never choose to work in an environment like that, but some people find themselves there without better options (e.g., being location-bound due to family, etc.).

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by bolasanibk on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:59AM (#42043506)
“Hire to fire”. Not a new idea. I have been hearing it for at least 5 years now.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by throwaway2037 on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:11AM (#42042227)
Wow, I never saw this type of advice before, but I like it. In short: If you are required to do stack ranking, where at least one person must get a shitty score/grade, then recruit someone internally who is below average and will take the hit. Brutal, but practical.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by ryandrake on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:38AM (#42043234)
Or externally! I posted an idea here a while ago, where I thought I'd start a staffing company called "Scapegoat Consultants" and we would offer your team a "low performer" that you could hire and then fire after a year, to protect the rest of your team from stack-ranking. Our consultant will join your team and do as little as you want, or even nothing at all! We'd guarantee that they will at least not actively make your code base worse, but that's it. After a year of this, you can easily make the case that our recruit was a low-performer and manage them out. Don't worry, he won't mind--his job was to be the low performer, and we'll hire him out to the next BigTech company who struggles with stack ranking.

It used to be tongue in cheek, but maybe the industry actually needs something like this.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Calamitous on Monday November 04, 2024 @01:57PM (#42044871)
Cynical, but probably the most humane take I’ve seen here so far.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by marcosdumay on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:56PM (#42046386)
That's the standard strategy to survive stack ranking.

Have you heard any story by someone that was hired into some megacorp just to be sent into a PIP or fired by low performance before they had any chance to even do anything? Stack ranking is the most common reason those happen.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by passwordoops on Monday November 04, 2024 @06:10AM (#42040492)
>the situation you describe is a classic sign of a shit manager

Well then it means the vast, vast, vast majority of companies with a coherent corporate structure are shit. Welcome to reality

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by red_admiral on Monday November 04, 2024 @08:50AM (#42041502)
I've had experience with internal "support" that marks tickets as closed without actually fixing the problem. Sometimes the reason for closing suggests they haven't even read the email that opened the ticket.

Think something like "Tool $X is missing on machine $Y. Please can you install it, according to $POLICY it is meant to be on all prod machines." Then the ticket gets closed with "The policy is correct. $X must be on all prod machines, we cannot change this." Without installing the tool.

Then when the annual anonymous "rate your satisfaction with these services" survey came round, they wondered why the ratings were so bad - I made sure in the open text feedback not to go after the poor employee but to raise concerns about the performance of the team manager. I won't take credit for it, but I'm told things at $COMPANY have got better since.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by dogleash on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:03AM (#42042144)
> a shit manager

This isn't about a singular individual, it's about a group of professionals. You have to deploy systems thinking. If you give a cohort a tool that allows and incentives them to do worse at their job, the average person in that group will perform worse.

I like my boss; I have also built a skillset and frugalness where I don't worry about working for someone I don't respect ever again. But I still care about what's going on at large and trends. I don't want downward pressure on the average. Not only will that slowly seep into effecting me, I also care about the lives of the people at points in their career where they don't have employment opportunities that allow them to avoid bad management.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by chipdart on Monday November 04, 2024 @12:21PM (#42043771)
> The metrics make reporting to higher ups easier, no doubt.

It's not about being "easy". It's about being objective, verifiable, and demonstratably unbiased. It's about justifying how you rank the performance in a way that's impossible to refute.

> But the situation you describe is a classic sign of a shit manager:

It's not, and frankly this "shit manager" accusation is an infantile remark that screams a failure to understand what it means to perform well.

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by BlueTemplar on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:14AM (#42040151)
It becomes an interesting contradiction : there's no such thing as a good unbiased and objective metric on this.

So good managers (that do their job properly) are bad managers (that get fired for it).

And bad managers are good managers...

Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by pxc on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:05AM (#42042162)
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by Brian_K_White on Monday November 04, 2024 @08:15AM (#42041230)
A manager can absolutely describe any value as simply as you just did.
Re:I've had a change of heart regarding employee metrics by jimberlage on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:23AM (#42042351)
One thing that is always on the table - if you see a person picking up valuable work and they don't have a ticket for it - you as a manager can create that ticket.

Now you may need to coach the person on how to do that themselves (can we make the ticket making process more lightweight? Can we make a heuristic like just put story points for the time you've already spent on it plus a buffer for after-the-fact work?)

But managers who really want documentation and truly think people are doing underappreciated work can always make it themselves.