News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by al_borland on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:08PM (#42027218)
He paid $11B in taxes in 2022, from what I could find. I don't see the US activity working to give that up, which would also send his multiple companies, some of which the government regularly does contracts with, to some other country. If they were to revoke it, I'm sure it would be a technicality and they'd give it right back to him.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:18PM (#42027296)
In discussions about this story on Reddit, people are calling for his companies to be forcibly taken away from him and nationalized. These suggestions are highly upvoted. It is interesting seeing how quickly they are ready to use authoritarianism against their political opponent.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by belter on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:20PM (#42027312)
Maybe they are just following Musk recommendation: "People who entered the country illegally should not be allowed to stay" - https://youtu.be/ZMQ2r3ofn80?t=3
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:43PM (#42027462)
He entered legally. He had a valid student visa. The allegation is that he worked while on his student visa, which is a restriction that does not really make sense anyways.

Regardless, the point about stopping illegal immigration is that we want skilled workers who contribute to society to stay, and we want to know who is entering so you don’t have bad actors like cartel members or CCP spies coming in. Obviously, Elon Musk has contributed more than virtually every other American and is a good actor.

> Even if USCIS had solid evidence that Musk had broken the law, it would, experts say, not handle the matter administratively, but rather could refer it to a US attorney’s office. Prosecutors, who have broad discretion to take up or decline cases, could then proceed, or not, as they saw fit.

Most US attorneys were appointed by Biden. So if they take this case up, it will be another obvious example of authoritarian lawfare.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:50PM (#42027506)
> Biden. So if they take this case up, it will be another obvious example of authoritarian lawfare

Your comment is much stronger without this.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:49PM (#42027910)
Seriously. Authoritarian lawfare? You mean against the guy who literally tried to steal the last election?
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by EasyMark on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:31PM (#42028640)
I don’t think that anyone who says following up on a coup attempt and constant attempts to overturn a presidential election as “law fare” is going to be open to your arguments. All one merely has to look at how many people around T went to jail for him, and somehow he managed to offload responsibility to them.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:59PM (#42027983)
> Authoritarian lawfare? You mean against the guy who literally tried to steal the last election?

Who are you responding to? OP referred to Biden as a purveyor of authoritarian lawfare. Which, given the term is flexibly defined, is both true for everyone and always falsifiable.

It's a stupid statement that follows an otherwise mostly thougtful comment. (Negating the "obviously...Musk...is a good actor" bit, but I'm not here to shit on faith.)

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:04PM (#42028021)
Sorry, I was doubling down and responding to blackeyeblitzar's comment. When people refer to Biden enacting "lawfare," it's frequently a right wing talking point used to discredit Jack Smith's cases against Trump.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:05PM (#42028030)
> When people refer to Biden enacting "lawfare," it's usually a right wing talking point used to discredit Jack Smith's cases against Trump

Oh, didn't know.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by slater on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:55PM (#42027553)
> Obviously, Elon Musk has contributed more than virtually every other American and is a good actor

Are you taking part in a "most citations needed in one sentence" competition?

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:15PM (#42027694)
Im not a right winger, but I think Musk has done more good for America than any other citizen in living memory. His work with Tesla advanced EV adoption in the US by many years and has also made grid scale battery storage a reality. SpaceX helped the US regain our lead in space infrastructure and brought internet to millions.

IF not for Musk, there would be a million more gas cars on the road, our grid would use more carbon, and we would probably still be launching our astronauts on Russian rockets.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by maximinus_thrax on Saturday November 02, 2024 @07:14PM (#42029942)
> He entered legally. He had a valid student visa.

https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2018/aug/24/kevin-mcca...

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @07:30PM (#42030003)
This wasn’t an overstay. He allegedly worked while on a student visa. But he had a valid visa then and after.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:41PM (#42027449)
People are tired of wealth superseding all law, precedent, and decorum.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by EasyMark on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:33PM (#42028649)
I strongly agree. Feds make examples of companies all the time, I don’t know why we would not do the same with a billionaire. I’m sure -many- hardworking people have been kicked out of the country for going against terms of their work/student/visitor visa, I don’t know why EM should be treated different. I thought justice was supposed to be blind.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:38PM (#42028694)
The disguising part is that he’s rubbing this in our faces while simultaneously relishing his party’s hardline stance on illegal immigration. He knows he’s above the law. He does not care about what the plebs think.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @05:25PM (#42029320)
Do you have any numbers on how many people have lost their citizenship for working on a student visa? Has it ever happened in the history of the USA?

Per this report, an average of 11 people are denaturalized per year, and it is reserved for terrorists and war criminals [1]

Why does everyone want to jump to conclusions about special treatment in the total absence of data? It is starting with the injustice one thinks is happening and presuming facts that make it true.

>Historically, the U.S. has reserved denaturalization proceedings for individuals who committed egregious crimes, including people who were found to be war criminals and terrorist funders. The most notable of those cases involved Nazi war criminals. For example, the federal government pursued and obtained the denaturalization of John (Ivan) Kalymon of Troy, Michigan in 2007 and his removal in 2011.

>https://immigrationforum.org/article/fact-sheet-on-denatural...

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:48PM (#42028776)
Why? Wealth is just what people are given by others through transactions. Shouldn’t the person be able to use it how they wish? I doubt Elon’s wealth was a problem for one half of the country when he voted for Biden a few years ago.

Also do you not see examples of those who aren’t wealthy breaking law or precedent or decorum? For example rampant retail and property crime in coastal cities. Or the mass rioting and destruction at the height of BLM. Or anti Israel terrorists blocking airports. Or the mass robbery of a freight train a week ago in Chicago. You can also find extreme rhetoric very easily in social media that supports the things you called out for “the other side”.

There is a much longer list of examples. The finger pointing around wealth doesn’t make sense to me. And if anything, Musk is doing far better than those attacking him.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by af3d on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:56PM (#42027561)
Funny how so many self-proclaimed "anti-fascists" also tend to be extremely pro-authoritarian. They want to censor the news, force companies to hire unqualified people for the sake of "equity", lock up politicians they do not like, and of course anyone who disagrees with them gets labeled, doxed, or even worse, etc, etc. Case in point, after the first Trump assassination attempt, over 50% of Democrats polled said that they were disappointed that the shooter failed! If that doesn't tell you the current state of "the Left", I don't know what does....
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:00PM (#42027591)
> want to censor the news, force companies to hire unqualified people for the sake of "equity", lock up politicians they do not like, and of course anyone who disagrees with them gets labeled, doxed, or even worse, etc, etc.

You’re cherry picking extreme policies that aren’t backed by most Americans, nor even a major plurality of either major party.

> over 50% of Democrats polled said that they were disappointed that the shooter failed

Partisanship drives stupidity. 70% of Republicans don’t believe the last election [1]. A fifth explicitly back violent insurrection [2]. We have a republic, not pure democracy, because the Founders weren’t idiots.

[1] https://www.politifact.com/article/2022/jun/14/most-republic...

[2] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:07PM (#42027634)
To be fair to the parent post, being a self proclaimed anti-fascists isn't a position held by most Americans. It seems they mean "anti-fascist" in terms of identity and ideology (aka antifa), not just holding the general sentiment that fascism is bad.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:11PM (#42027663)
> seems they mean "anti-fascist" in terms of identity and ideology (aka antifa)

Fair enough. I’d still be surprised if a majority of those who identify with antifa support each of those policies. Maybe one.

But most people support at least one stupid policy. It’s why dictatorship doesn’t work.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:24PM (#42027747)
In my experience, there is significant cross over between antifa and communists seeking a dictatorship of the proletariat. That said, I agree the policies listed are more than your typical authoritarianism.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:38PM (#42027831)
> there is significant cross over between antifa and communists seeking a dictatorship of the proletariat

Sure. But again: there is a significant crossover between Democrats and lefties who want to strip an American of their citizenship as well as between Republicans and jackbooters who support violent insurrection against an elected government.

Every human being holds at least one incredibly stupid opinion. My self included. "There is an idiot in that room" isn't a novel nor damning observation about any group. Because it's true about every group.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:49PM (#42027912)
I totally agree. I wish people spent half as much time examining their own positions for coherence and hypocrisy as they spent examining those of their political opponents.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by al_borland on Sunday November 03, 2024 @01:30AM (#42031331)
Reddit turned on Musk as soon as he started nearing the top of the Forbes list. They rooted for him to be successful, and when he was, they hated him for it. The reductionist, "rich == bad", thinking on Reddit was one of the many things that drove me away from the site.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @12:48PM (#42027496)
> don't see the US activity working to give that up

It’s the law. Which means it’s an option. My takeaway is the law should be amended to include a statute of limitations. (More broadly, I'm not thrilled about how comfortable both parties have become around talking of stripping citizenship.)

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:48PM (#42027903)
I’ve never heard of any Democratic party leaders talk about stripping citizenship. Did I miss something?
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:05PM (#42028028)
> I’ve never heard of any Democratic party leaders talk about stripping citizenship

Fair enough, no leadership to my knowledge.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:46PM (#42028766)
Why would they talk about it? They’re the main beneficiaries of illegal immigration and its effects on long term voting outcomes.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by archagon on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:49PM (#42028785)
In what ways are they the beneficiaries of illegal immigration? Illegal immigrants don’t vote, and their descendants are often conservative.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday November 02, 2024 @04:02PM (#42028876)
A nonzero number of illegal immigrants do vote. I don’t know if there is data on how often (my guess is it is rare). But when it is caught, the vote remains counted.

As for descendants, they vote mostly for democrats. I don’t have a source on hand but I’m sure it is easy to find. You can also look at data by ethnicity instead of immigration status to get an idea. Also this skews other parts of the political process, outside of the presidency.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 03, 2024 @03:07AM (#42031787)
> nonzero number of illegal immigrants do vote

This hypothesis has been tested. Lots of people have spent a lot of time and money on it. We have zero examples. The only voter fraud we have found is right wing idiots who don’t understand the electoral college.

Believing in voter fraud is not quite flat Earth stupid. But it’s close.

> As for descendants, they vote mostly for democrats

Racial depolarisation is the term you’re looking for. Young single men vote Trump. Also, whose donors do you think hire illegal workers? Who pushes back on strict liability for employers?

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by blackeyeblitzar on Sunday November 03, 2024 @06:41AM (#42032501)
> This hypothesis has been tested. Lots of people have spent a lot of time and money on it. We have zero examples.

Literally this week: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/10/31/michigan-...

> Believing in voter fraud is not quite flat Earth stupid. But it’s close.

Blind faith is more like “flat Earth” to me. Does it make sense to have such confidence about every election on the planet? Or is America on a pedestal? Those other countries probably make the same claims about their alleged election integrity.

> Also, whose donors do you think hire illegal workers? Who pushes back on strict liability for employers?

I would ask to share your sources but why is this even relevant? Voter ID now. Closed borders now. Deportation for illegal immigrants now. No one buys the weird excuses conjured up by untrustworthy politicians and activists on this issue, not even them. It is clear who this status quo favors.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 03, 2024 @01:28PM (#42034979)
> Literally this week

N != 0, it’s less than 1/10^8 over multiple cycles. Which means zero examples in modern America of a national election being stolen through fraud.

> Blind faith

To the degree there is blind faith in this discussion it’s from the election deniers. Polls are heavily scrutinised by not only multiple layers of government, but also various outside groups, including the campaigns, as well as international bodies. One has to assume widespread conspiracy across those groups—and then be too lazy to observe a poll oneself—to conclude fraud. Not only forward looking, but worse, backward looking given the millions of dollars spent on hand recounting ballots in e.g. Arizona.

> Voter ID now

I vote in a state with a voter ID requirement. Maybe those who think these laws do something didn’t go to college. I can’t think of any other reason for the widespread amnesia around the prevalence and accessibility of fake IDs. (And you could vote with a cheap one, too. Nobody checks if they scan.)

> Closed borders now. Deportation for illegal immigrants now

About as relevant to election security as abortion and speed limits.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:52PM (#42027930)
For that matter, I haven't heard any Republican party leaders taking about stripping Musk's citizenship, either.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:05PM (#42028025)
> I haven't heard any Republican party leaders taking about stripping Musk's citizenship, either

DHS established a "denaturalisation task force" in 2018. Stripping Americans of citizenship

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:24PM (#42028583)
Sure. Did they (or anyone) say they were going to strip Musk of citizenship? (al_borland's original claim was specifically about Musk's citizenship, not citizenship in general.)
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:43PM (#42028740)
No, nobody real is talking about taking Musk’s citizenship. Hell, he hasn’t even lost his security clearance. Those are granted on the basis of executive order. It’s at the pleasure of the President. Nobody is going after Musk.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by Zigurd on Saturday November 02, 2024 @06:07PM (#42029544)
That was a trump campaign promise. Apparently they 10X'ed denaturalizations. So, I'd say that's in play.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by Zigurd on Saturday November 02, 2024 @06:05PM (#42029534)
Re citizenship I would agree. Denaturalization is rare. The visa as a lesser issue compared to having Vlad as a chat buddy while owning Xitter. There are two problems with that: Not filing disclosure immediately gets your clearance yanked. Secondly, it could bring in FARA requirements, which is also incompatible with having a clearance.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by EasyMark on Saturday November 02, 2024 @03:26PM (#42028601)
The law is the law. He has no right to not be subject to the same laws as you or I. If we’ve done the same to other immigrants, it’s only fair that once the authorities are made aware of it that they investigate. No one should be able to buy themselves a carve out from the law. If the precedent is that nothing has really done about it in the past then do that as well, but no reason he should be above the law.
Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by root_axis on Saturday November 02, 2024 @04:24PM (#42028996)
> No one should be able to buy themselves a carve out from the law

Yet this is the reality as far back as I can remember. The gravity of that much wealth inevitably distorts the fabric of the legal system.

We've seen stuff like this play out over and over again among rich politicians, celebrities, CEOs etc. We also see it with wealthy businesses that cynically violate the law based on a favorable cost benefit analysis, not to mention their pervasive lobbying that literally defines the law. Even among the less affluent classes, we still see a stratification in practical impunity to break the law since e.g. it's a lot more tempting to speed if a speeding ticket is as trivial as a plane ticket. In our system, everything has a price.

However, if Musk was an illegal immigrant (yes, violating the terms of your visa is illegal, and it's the most common form of illegal immigration) I do think Musk's hypocrisy is quite disgusting. I can admit that if he were more humble and respectful of the immigrant experience he shares with those he maligns, I would be more sympathetic to him.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by s1artibartfast on Saturday November 02, 2024 @05:18PM (#42029278)
>If we’ve done the same to other immigrants...

I dont think citizenship has ever been taken away from another immigrant 30 years after the fact for working on a student visa.

There have only been a several hundred denaturalized immigrants in the history of the US, and they were for things like false identity with outstanding deportation orders.

Re:Musk Could Have US Citizenship Revoked If He Lied on Immi... by tim333 on Sunday November 03, 2024 @08:53AM (#42033052)
True, no way he gets deported but it's kind of ironic given him going on about the need to deport other illegal immigrants. I think the moral is US immigration is a mess and needs an overhaul.