Re:Nvidia to join Dow Jones Industrial Average, replacing Intel
by llm_trw on Saturday November 02, 2024 @01:33AM
(#42024265)
Did you ever train anything past mnist on AMD? I try every five years or so and promise myself never again each and every time.
Re:Nvidia to join Dow Jones Industrial Average, replacing Intel
by dagmx on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:17AM
(#42024396)
Not with Rocm since I’ve moved my personal stack to NVIDIA (for rendering) and Macs for day to day use.
I did write quite a bit of OpenCL prior to that on Intel/AMd/NVIDIA, both for training and for general rendering though, and did some work with Stream before then.
Re:Nvidia to join Dow Jones Industrial Average, replacing Intel
by llm_trw on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:46AM
(#42024506)
Was it OpenCL1? That's the only one I hadn't tried out for AMD GPUs. Everything else I have and can say with absolute certainty that you spend more time fighting the hardware than you did writing code.
Cuda by comparison JustWorks^tm.
Re:Nvidia to join Dow Jones Industrial Average, replacing Intel
by dagmx on Saturday November 02, 2024 @02:57AM
(#42024547)
Both 1 and 2. I haven’t done much with 3 as OpenCL is effectively a dead api at this point.
1 was definitely a lot easier to work with than 2. CUDA is easier than both but I don’t think I hit anything I could do in CUDA that I couldn’t do in OpenCL, though CUDA of course had a larger ecosystem of existing libraries.
That said ROCm is quite a recent thing borne out of acknowledging that OpenCL 2 was a disaster.
OpenCL 1 had a reasonable shot and was gaining adoption but 2 scuppered it.