News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jablan on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:21AM (#4202086)
Does anyone else have difficulties reading articles written this way - structured as Hollywood movies, with artificially built-up suspense and all? I feel patronized all the time, trying to get to the "meat" of the article, just finding "next page" link instead.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by yock on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:45AM (#4202771)
No. Long-form journalism is about keeping the reader engaged in a story they didn't know they wanted to hear. You wouldn't write fiction with a strict focus on the sequence of events, why should this be any different? While you're feeling patronized I find that I enjoy the engagement. Frankly, your way sounds boring.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @09:34AM (#4202924)
I'm glad to know that at least someone enjoys this style, because I am with jablan; I hate it. To me, it suggests that the author doesn't expect me to find the content interesting, and that instead this content has to be packaged with (predictable) human-interest intrigue just to get me to read it.

To me, it's very analogous to trying to teach students math with colorful, picture-laden textbooks: it might be necessary for students who will never learn much math in order to just get them to pass the grade, but insofar as it works such students are not getting deep appreciation for the concepts.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by yock on Thursday July 05, 2012 @09:48AM (#4202978)
But, this isn't math! It's a story, with characters and a plot. The intrigue is baked-in because it makes for an enjoyable read. Sure, the details are interesting, but there's nothing wrong with telling an interesting story with interesting details in an interesting way. "First this happened and then this happened and then this happened..." is not how you tell a story, regardless of whether or not the story happens to be factual.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:16AM (#4203094)
If I want an artistic short story in magazine form, I'll read the New Yorker. But this is Wired, and the material facts of this story are the only interesting part.

I guess it's possible that a gifted author could wrap these fact with a human-interest element in a way that is worthwhile while still communicating an essential idea ("The Last Question" by Asimov comes to mind). But, by experience, this just isn't within the abilities of most magazine writers. And it doesn't need to be, because the material facts are plenty interesting on their own.

Edit: I can't reply to vacri, so I'll follow up to his comment here. Vacri: human interest pieces have been around for decades. Furthermore, the newspaper format of most journalism (one sentence paragraphs, most important facts at the top regardless of sensible narrative order, negligible artistic flourishes) were set a century ago. I'm pretty young (26), but I've read newspapers from before the internet and they did plenty of bad human-interest stories. I'm pretty skeptical that the internet had much of an impact in this respect. Maybe you have a more specific source, or I misunderstand your claim?

Edit 2, reply to fiatpandas: I think the distinction between an AP-style newspaper article and a human-interest short story is a false dichotomy. Instead, there is a middle option of a fact-focused piece designed to clearly communicate the essential ideas without relying on artistic/narrative devices to keep the reader's attention. (See my reply to jablan http://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=4203567) Wired can choose whatever style it wants, (and I certainly have no doubt they've done this plenty in the past) but my claim is that the human-interest style is almost always poorly executed. If the facts are interesting enough, then it's unnecessary, and if they aren't, then it's a waste.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by fiatpandas on Thursday July 05, 2012 @11:54AM (#4203547)
>But this is Wired

You make it seem like these long-form narrative articles are a totally foreign concept to Wired, like this is a one-off piece that somehow slipped past the Wired editors who want brief pieces for the internet generation. Not true at all.

This article is nothing compared to a piece Neal Stephenson wrote about a trans-Atlantic fiber optic cable. It's hilariously long and pretty epic. I guess in your case I wouldn't recommend it, though.

http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html

I don't know, man. I'm all for AP-length news stories about current events (I don't want to read artistic prose about every little news event), but sometimes it's fun and interesting to transcend the typical format. I'm one year younger than you, by the way, just so you don't think this is a generational issue.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by vacri on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:43AM (#4203225)
This was the format that a lot of good journalism used to be in, before the internet chopped up everyone's attention span into bite-sized bits.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by sophacles on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:47PM (#4204031)
the material facts of this story are the only interesting part.

The facts are simple:

1. some guy made good counterfeit money

2. he got caught through a series of mistakes

a. sloppy waste disposal

b. over trusting

This is the same pattern as for most crimes. Seriously, minus the murder bit, it's a law and order episode. What I want to know, is not the predictable sequence of events, but who would do this, why would they do this, tell me the thought process that leads to these actions.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:37PM (#4204298)
> This is the same pattern as for most crimes. Seriously, minus the murder bit, it's a law and order episode.

I guess that's why the original Law & Order is one of the few TV shows I like.

> What I want to know, is not the predictable sequence of events, but who would do this, why would they do this, tell me the thought process that leads to these actions.

I also want to know all this, so I think you may have misunderstood my position. (This applies to your other comment where you call me disingenuous for no good reason.) What I don't want is stuff like "Tourists milled about the platz in front of the cathedral, Germany’s most visited landmark, craning their necks to snap pictures of the impossibly intricate spires jutting toward the heavens.", nor do I want teaser paragraphs endings to keep me hooked on the article as if I would stop reading it without them.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by sophacles on Thursday July 05, 2012 @03:39PM (#4204604)
Perhaps you have a perfect geographical understanding of the world, but I would have no idea what this alternative sentence would mean (which i constructed by my best understanding of what you claim to want):

A meeting was arranged in near the Cathedral in Cologne.

To me, that leaves a ton of questions:

How busy is this place? What are the odds a meeting would seem out of place? What is the tenor of the crowd? Who would be paying attention to a meeting and noticing?

Further, I would be curious, but not frustratingly so, about what the setting in general looked like. I'm a visual person, I like when an author helps me, visualize what I'm reading, it makes my comprehension easier.

I maintain that you are being disingenuous, because you are refusing to accept that others may find this stuff useful, because you don't and therefore suggest all things be done to your preference. Like I said, don't read something from a source known to do this. Find the AP feed instead, because some of us actually get better understanding from articles written like this.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by fiatpandas on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:56PM (#4204082)
In response to your reply to me:

I think we're both arguing with emotion here. You said you hated the style and it's rarely done well. I happen to think that Wired isn't a scholarly journal, and fact + emotional narrative can be really enjoyable to read if used appropriately (and I happened to enjoy reading the article). I guess I'm objecting to how you evaluated an entire genre of narrative style. There is irony in using your emotional response to a writing style to argue for a more objective or scientific approach to journalism.

TLDR: "It's not science"

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @02:34PM (#4204280)
I have an emotional response to crappy statistical analyses too (really), but that hardly negates any critique of such an analysis I would write.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jablan on Thursday July 05, 2012 @11:16AM (#4203381)
I think the problem here is the motivation for reading. I enjoy reading fiction, love watching movies etc. But I clicked the link to the Wired article to learn something new. If I get entertained too, it's just a bonus, but it's entirely optional. Journalism even has a term for what I ask for, they call it "inverted pyramid"[1]. All the petty details intended to spice-up a story are welcome, but they should be placed appropriately, and should be easy to skim over. And this article is a perfect counter-example.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @11:58AM (#4203567)
The concept of an inverted pyramid isn't quite what you're looking for here, is it? The inverted pyramid is the idea that a newspaper article leads with the most important facts first, followed by lesser and lesser details, so that one will always have read the most important facts for a given amount of reading no matter how long that amount of reading is.

But that's not really the problem with the Wired article. It's not in a newspaper, so it's legitimate to write it assuming the reader will read the whole thing. It's perfectly fine for the author to tell the story in chronological order (or whatever order is appropriate for communicating the important ideas).

Instead, I think the problem you and I have with it are the unnecessary artistic flourishes and the non-standard chronology designed to "pull" the reader into the article. Does anyone know what this aspect is called?

Edit: On second thought, maybe I'm just projecting. Do you really think that this article would have been better as a reverse pyramid?

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by stevejalim on Thursday July 05, 2012 @05:43AM (#4202372)
I think a great part of that frustration is down to long-form magazine features being ported to wired.com, where brevity is better suited to the web-page form.

Personally, I think almost all of the writing in Wired is excellent - well crafted and edited and laid out within interesting designs. Yes, while there are pretty common 'paint a picture' set-ups and more detail about the actual people involved than you'd get in news (for sure) and non-US feature writing (my view), that's part of the reason I keep buying the US print copy of Wired (even in the UK), and enjoy settling down to read it.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @09:28AM (#4202902)
I have the exact same revulsion to this style writing when I see it in print. The only upside is that, in print, it's easier for me to skip through the article and get to the actual content.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by sophacles on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:51PM (#4204053)
See the think you are doing here is being completely and utterly disingenuous. What you are talking about as content is a list of facts of the event. What you are pissed about is a list of facts about the person involved. I like the facts about the person involved, the circumstance and some speculation about their mindset. I like that, if you want facts about the sequence of events, read a crime report. Or even better, don't read the article, you don't have to just because it is there. If you have revulsion, find a medium that works for you, they exist, don't complain.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by AYBABTME on Thursday July 05, 2012 @05:00AM (#4202269)
I feel the same. I don't care about the biography of the person being investigated, I just want to know the stuff related to the meat of the article. For instance, I don't want to know about this man's passion for Andy Warhol. Or that previous article about a woman who stood up against Citibank: I really didn't care about her love for horses and that she's a cowgirl or whatever.

But that's just a pointless rant, and I only share it because you raised the question. The appropriate way to deal with this would be to identify authors who tend to write in this style, and avoid reading them. I don't pretend they're bad, it's just their style doesn't fit my tastes.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by jessriedel on Thursday July 05, 2012 @09:38AM (#4202940)
Eh. I think there's value in making people cognizant of this style by discussing the way it works. It certainly took my a few years before I could pinpoint exactly why I disliked this stuff.

Also, there's so many magazine authors out there that keeping track of their individual styles it pretty hopeless for me. The best I can do is remember that Wired is written like this.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by SilasX on Thursday July 05, 2012 @08:24AM (#4202724)
Agree 100%. I'm saying this all the time. Please, writer, just get to the point! I don't want to learn a zillion details about everything you saw.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by vacri on Thursday July 05, 2012 @10:46AM (#4203238)
Do you complain that movies take too long with the plot when you haven't seen the villain vanquished by the 5-minute mark?
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by SilasX on Thursday July 05, 2012 @11:05AM (#4203330)
No. Movies are there primarily to entertain. News stories are there to inform. If I wanted the dramatic, drawn-out version, I'd see the "based on a true story!" version.

There are lots of events I could be learning about in a day, and I'd like to be able to get the important stuff out of a new story and go on to the other stuff. In contrast, you can't similarly shorten a movie while sticking to its purpose (usually).

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by apendleton on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:41PM (#4204005)
Who said it was a news story? It's not about an especially current event, and Wired is not a news magazine (for that, see Newsweek, Time, or any number of others); they're a tech/nerd culture periodical. They've has always had a major focus on long-form journalism.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by sophacles on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:52PM (#4204060)
Then don't read stories from sources that are known to contextualize rather than report the facts. It's like you keep touching a hot stove, and complain how it keeps burning you.
Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by SilasX on Thursday July 05, 2012 @04:11PM (#4204738)
Who said I did? Of course I ignore such stories, or skim past the first 15 paragraphs to get to the meat.

If I want a page turner, I'll get a novel. For news stories, I just want the information. Time spent learning about the color of the subjects coat is time I could spend reading another story, learning something useful, or entertaining myself through a medium actually optimized for that.

Re:The Ultimate Counterfeiter Isn’t a Crook — He’s an Artist by sophacles on Thursday July 05, 2012 @05:30PM (#4205069)
Oh right. I forgot you are the sole arbiter of what is entertaining or useful to learn. My bad, I'll go figure out how to stop being entertained by long-form journalism stories like this. My bad.