News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by kulahan on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:42PM (#42000036)
Can't wait to find out what China hid in Riot's Vanguard rootkit for all their games. It's 100% a conspiracy theory, but nobody can convince me it's perfectly clean, or if it is, that there isn't an easy way to add some power to it quietly.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Levitating on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @08:07PM (#42002048)
The vanguard drivers are signed by Microsoft, the procedure for which includes a safety audit by Microsoft.

The driver is just what the developers say it is (as with all other anti-cheat). It provides an untempered interface for the userland anti-cheat to use to get info from the kernel. Because modern cheats tend to alter the output of kernel syscalls by running in the kernel themselves.

I really don't see why anyone needs to think it's anything more than that.

If Tencent needed to spy on you so badly there's no reason kernel anti-cheats need anything to do with it...

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by cmxch on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @08:27PM (#42002171)
It says something about Microsoft when they OK a known harmful bootkit that expects your computer to act like an XBox with a fancy keyboard (but not too fancy), requests invasive changes to UEFI that have broken systems, and have an overall opacity that rivals an Arthur C. Clarke Monolith.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by gruez on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @10:29PM (#42002849)
>The vanguard drivers are signed by Microsoft, the procedure for which includes a safety audit by Microsoft.

Did the crowdstrike driver get the same audit?

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by 15155 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @11:42PM (#42003277)
EAC and other kernel-level anticheat software will dynamically load and execute signed payloads at runtime. Does Vanguard do this? If so, does Microsoft check these payloads?
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Levitating on Thursday October 31, 2024 @08:26AM (#42006171)
> EAC and other kernel-level anticheat software will dynamically load and execute signed payloads at runtime

Are you sure about that?

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by 15155 on Thursday October 31, 2024 @03:49PM (#42010756)
100%
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by perillamint on Thursday October 31, 2024 @12:56AM (#42003631)
MS usually don't bother with driver audit... They mostly rely on EV certificate to check driver dev is a proper legal entity.

If they audit properly, they should not let the Asus AuraSync driver certified at the first time. (basically opens PORT instruction to every userland app, unristricted)

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Hikikomori on Thursday October 31, 2024 @11:21AM (#42007817)
Drivers are generally not audited by Microsoft to be signed, you only need to register your EV cert to get it signed. Cheat developers have registered their own/gotten their hands on EV certificates to create a kernel driver cheats. Anti cheat like Battleeye also download anti cheat modules at runtime to obfuscate what they do.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by kulahan on Thursday October 31, 2024 @11:34AM (#42007935)
The level of sophistication that can go into a hack when sponsored by a nation-state is incredible. Just remember Stuxnet all the way back in '06 or whatever it was. Tech was a lot less advanced nearly two decades ago. It's not right, imo, to leave your safety up to this process.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by PaulHoule on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:24PM (#42000533)
If it is written in C you can always introduce a buffer overflow or something similar by just adding a little bit of line noise here or there and nobody can prove it was deliberate.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by throwaway48476 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:27PM (#42000568)
It's closed source and the assembly is obfuscated. You don't even need to bother with plausible debiability.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:35PM (#42000657)
Surely the NSA has tools, people, resources etc to figure that out?
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by throwaway48476 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:44PM (#42000744)
Dedicated to reverse engineering every update to vanguard? Huge waste of effort. They would probably just steal the source code.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Maken on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @07:26PM (#42001714)
The NSA just needs a call to Riot headquarters to ensure their rootkit is also included.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by throwaway48476 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:05PM (#42000292)
China's national security assistance law came up in the TikTok hearings. There's no reason to believe that the CCP doesn't have the legal authority to compel Riot to push an update with a backdoor to a few select high value targets.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by gorjusborg on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:15PM (#42000408)
Companies rule the United States. Companies that do business in China are ruled by China. Therefore, the United States is ruled by China.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by vkou on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:05PM (#42000970)
The same line of thinking leads me to conclude that the world is ruled by the United States.

Can we stop with the nationalistic hyperbole already, and discuss acute issues, instead of vague fingerwaving at the foreign boogieman?

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by gorjusborg on Friday November 01, 2024 @09:21AM (#42016694)
I wasn't being serious.

Sorry to offend your motherland. You deserve all the social credit coming to you.

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by jsheard on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:45PM (#42000064)
If I wanted to deploy a trojan horse then the last place I would try to hide it is in an anti-cheat driver that will without any doubt be exhaustively analysed by people attempting to bypass it.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by bravetraveler on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:54PM (#42000177)
Gamers are great targets. They'll disable security for higher polling rates. Not discerning, gladly walk to the slaughterhouse.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by phito on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:12PM (#42000374)
There's a ton of gamers that like to figure out how the game itself works. There's a ton of them trying to figure out how anti cheats work, sometimes to cheat, but more often because they're curious, resourceful teenagers taking it as a challenge.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by bravetraveler on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:13PM (#42001056)
Oh, I know. That's how my career was started. I made invitational in CS: Source (CAL) and then sold cheats to pay for college. My first Real Job was through a teammate.

Far more would have accepted a RAT and been deprived money than expressed genuine interest. Some did... not many. Most wanted the acclaim without the effort.

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @05:36PM (#42000679)
But also there's parties there with a big interest in circumventing these securities, and have done so for decades. The new release of RDR for PC (shamefully asking $50 for a 14 year old game) was cracked within days, if not earlier, of its releae.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by vkou on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:06PM (#42000983)
Ah, yes, for most of us, getting our computer pwned is just like being murdered.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by bravetraveler on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:08PM (#42001008)
l o l

Fine, they'll gladly eat shit

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by vkou on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:23PM (#42001162)
How much shit, and how does it compare to the risk profile of, say, not wearing a five points seat belt and motorcycling helmet while driving, or a bulletproof vest when going to school, or an N95 mask literally everywhere?

Security theorists are always ready to tell us about the horrifying risks of installing kernel-level code from a vendor, but can they actually quantify the likelihood times damage those billions of installations have inflicted on Joe Random's life?

And contrast them to other risks that we regularly take in the name of comfort and convenience?

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by kelnos on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:34PM (#42001255)
Funny that you initially used "Joe Ransom" as your example name (before your edit), as that describes one of the possible situations our friend Joe can end up in: malware that encrypts all his data and asks for a ransom to get it back.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by vkou on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:43PM (#42001323)
Its possible. Roughly how likely is that to happen to him from installing a game with EAC? Are there a lot of documented cases of this?

Is it more or less likely than them dying from the 'Rona because they didn't wear an N95 24/7?

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by bravetraveler on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @06:27PM (#42001208)
I'm not really that interested in chasing this, but a point I do want to make: it isn't just risk.

If you want to participate in a lot of these multiplayer games that place cheating far too highly, you can't use a hypervisor. You must have gaming device and computing device. They cannot be the same.

That's fine for most, but I consider it shit. VFIO makes it possible for a big computer to make a smaller gaming one. Ask me how I know.

My greater point is I don't care if I get cheated out of a finals match. I can actually speak from experience. I prefer autonomy over my devices. I kind of want to eat poop with them. A little.

Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by throwaway48476 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:47PM (#42000091)
State sponsored actors only target a few people and they only send the backdoored version to their target list.
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by thesuitonym on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:57PM (#42000205)
Ah yes, that’s why stuxnet wasn’t a big deal
Re:Steam games will need to disclose kernel-level anti-cheat... by throwaway48476 on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:59PM (#42000235)
What do you mean? They burned several high value 0days on a high value target. Why wouldn't China burn a high value backdoor on a target they deem valuable enough.