Re:When are two proofs essentially the same? (2007)
by justinpombrio on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @11:25AM
(#41996059)
You're handwaving, but I think there is a middle-ground in this proof:
Sum(i=1..n, i)
= Sum(i=1..n/2, i) + Sum(i=1..n/2, n+1-i)
= Sum(i=1..n/2, n+1)
I'm still interested in the general question, of whether some proofs have big gaps between them. The more complex the proofs, the more obvious this would be; my examples are unfortunately simple. Something like proving the fundamental theorem of algebra using Rouche's Theorem (complex analysis) vs. field theory. But I don't know enough math to compare those.
Sum(i=1..n, i)
= Sum(i=1..n/2, i) + Sum(i=1..n/2, n+1-i)
= Sum(i=1..n/2, n+1)
I'm still interested in the general question, of whether some proofs have big gaps between them. The more complex the proofs, the more obvious this would be; my examples are unfortunately simple. Something like proving the fundamental theorem of algebra using Rouche's Theorem (complex analysis) vs. field theory. But I don't know enough math to compare those.