Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
by scubbo on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:41PM
(#41991769)
> a bunch of people trying to use a hammer when they needed a screwdriver and then complaining that the hammer didnt work like a screwdriver
When it's being sold as a screwdriver, that's hardly their fault.
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
by fullstackchris on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @04:05AM
(#41992800)
I'll give you that! Too much of this stuff is sold as the "magic wand" solution... I guess marketing for many products has been like that for a long time...
Re:GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
by nprateem on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @02:27AM
(#41992332)
I'm sure people who are "terrified" either haven't really tried AI or are so attached to their intellect their egos won't allow them to admit that there's little value now in a lot of the stuff they've memorised over the last few years.
I think this egoic threat is the biggest influence on this kind of thinking tbh.
At the end of the day, we're engineers that write complex symbols on a 2d canvas, for something that is (ultimately, even if the code being written is machine to machine or something) used for some human purpose.
Now, if those complex symbols are readable, fully covered in tests, and meets requirements / specifications, I don't see why I should care if a human, an AI, or a monkey generated those symbols. If it meets the spec, it meets the spec.
Seems like most people in these threads are making arguments against others who are describing usage of these tools in a grossly incorrect manner from the get go.
I've said it before in other AI threads that I think (at least half?) of the noise and disagreement around AI generated code is like a bunch of people trying to use a hammer when they needed a screwdriver and then complaining that the hammer didnt work like a screwdriver!!! I just don't get it. When you're dealing with complex systems, i.e, reality, these tools (or any tool for that matter) will never work like a magic wand.