News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:10AM (#4198856)
As someone else pointed out, the concept of Intellectual Property, its goals, and how it is enforced continues to diverge on the two sides of the Atlantic, which is probably a good thing.
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by flyinRyan on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:16AM (#4199278)
This probably comes down to the kinds of democracies. In the US we have a two party system where both candidates are the same in most cases. Do you want to vote pro ACTA or pro ACTA?
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:22AM (#4199308)
Well, the UK (where I'm from) isn't much better. I'd call it 2.5 party system. Two large parties: Labour (centre-left), Conservative (centre-right), and the small Liberal Democrats (centre to centre-left), and the minority parties. But both Labour and the Conservatives keep moving closer to the centre. And quite a lot of issues you wouldn't have any choice on. For instance, same-sex marriage: Do you want same-sex marriage, same-sex marriage, or same-sex marriage?
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by Silhouette on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:15AM (#4199701)
If you look at how many votes they pick up, there isn't such a wide gap between the top three parties, and several of the minorities take a substantial share too. However, our first-past-the-post system for general elections magnifies any differences. Usually this gives the largest party a disproportionate number of MPs and often an absolute majority. On the other hand, it potentially gives a lot of influence to even very small parties if there is a stalemate between the two largest parties that means neither can form a government alone. So perhaps it's not so much that we have a 2.5 party system, but more that votes count on a very non-linear scale.

Incidentally, I would characterise both Labour since Blair and the Conservatives as being some way to the right on most social and economic issues. It's not yet clear how much Miliband, E. will bring things back to Labour's more traditional left-wing stance. The Liberal Democrats still seem to be quite left-wing in principle, even if they have to temper that to some extent while they are in a coalition government. I'm not sure we really have a mainstream moderate/centre party in English politics today, though obviously none of our major parties are as polarized/extreme as in some places.

Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by Aqwis on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:13AM (#4199469)
Should one of the parties also support slavery just so that you have a choice? Eventually an issue reaches a point where the vast majority of the population supports an issue (such as keeping slavery illegal), and when that happens it shouldn't be a surprise that no parties are against it. I hope and think this is what has happened to the issue of same-sex marriage in the UK.
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:17AM (#4199483)
Oh of course. I'm in favour of same-sex marriage, personally, and I like the fact almost every important party supports it.

I'm just using it as an example of something that there is very little real democratic choice on, however.

Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by vacri on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:22PM (#4201369)
Where 'vast majority' can equal 55%. Or not even then - sometimes an issue is not worth fighting over compared to others. Most people want to pay less tax, for example, but politicians of all stripes know that's not feasible, and stick with the minority desire to keep taxes up and focus on other things.

Another thing that politicians are great at ignoring is the general public's disdain for their paypackets. On this issue, even the most brazen shouter of 'my mandate comes from the people' turns to 'this is a delicate issue that the public don't understand'...

Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by J3L2404 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @01:53PM (#4200244)
I think it will be quite a long time, if ever, that all parties will agree there should be no intellectual property.
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by praptak on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:15AM (#4199700)
I believe that two party is the lesser of your problems. The huge dependence of Congress on lobbyist money is worse. The whole system is basically legalized corruption.
Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by cremnob on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @02:21PM (#4200333)
Companies have every right to crack down on copyright infringement.

This is a victory against a piece of legislation that was overreaching, potentially harmful to entirely innocent parties, and could have caused censorship across the internet. A lot of people (mostly reddit users) seem to think that there is now some automatic right to download shit for free whenever you want, and we should be protected by law to be able to do this. That's just greedy entitlement. And that's not what this is about. Everyone deserves to be paid for their work, whether it's you, me or a corporation (which often employs people like you and me anyway). The point in this case, is that authorities went too far down the road of infringement of people's genuine rights in trying to protect corporate profits.

I'm sure there will be those who disagree, but taking other people's work without their permission isn't morally justifiable whichever way you try to spin it. Regardless of who made it. And that's not what we should be fighting for. This is not, and should not be a "victory for piracy". It's about our freedom as individuals not to be treated like de facto criminals by our own governments.

Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by cdcox on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:11PM (#4200716)
It's easy to rant for or against this. On a flipside:

1. Copyright is deeply broken. It currently extends well beyond any reasonable interpretation of it's original purpose.

2. You can't enter a medium and regulate it so you can do business. The standard rules and metaphors of IP don't apply as well to digital distribution. The easiest way to prevent copyrighted work from being distributed is to not digitize it. Very few books and comics were being illegally downloaded before they started epubing them. But you can't pretend you have the right to a law on medium with a structure counter to that law.

3. "Everyone deserves to be paid for their work" is false. Everyone who does work, which can be sold in the current market, given the current realities of the world, and who price and distribute their product properly should be paid for their work. If I go clean up a public park, I have no right to charge admission. If I build a statue in a public space, I can't charge people to look at it, even if they come from far away to see it.

Everyone deserves to get a part of any profit derived from their work, is a more correct statement.

Re:ACTA killed in EU parliament: 478 votes to 39 by TazeTSchnitzel on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:22PM (#4200572)
Your point being?

I never said anything about piracy.