Re:Gravity is not a force
by hnuser123456 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @03:41PM
(#41988501)
If you have a given velocity but no given starting position, then position is the missing constant. If you measure some acceleration and time, you can integrate that into a delta-velocity, but not an absolute velocity.
You can measure your speed against the CMB as an "absolute velocity" (in your local observable universe), but for two locations that are a significant fraction of the width of the observable universe apart, "zero movement" relative to the CMB in each of those locations, will not be zero movement relative to each other, due to the expansion of space in between.
It took me a while to understand your second para.
I found a lot more on the broader topic here.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach%27s_principle
It mentions that rotational motion does seem to have an absolute reference frame.
Losely speakimg, we have F=ma. Since a second derivative of position is involved, in the integral forms with velocity and position, we have constants of integration unresolved, which leaves no absolute frame of reference.
So the spacetime somehow has it that absolute measurements are for acceleration, which implies there is an absolute recerence frame for acceleration. I wonder if this implies a higher order relativity is present or waiting to be found.
Rotational motion feels still more strange. Here, even though angular momentum is conserved, rotational velocity still seems absolute. If it weren't, then distance objects in some rotational reference frame would be moving faster than the speed of light, unless there's some relativistic modification to v = omega * r.
I do not know if I understand these things right.