News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by whartung on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:57PM (#41986542)
So, do you think that when the Mac Studio gets upgraded, it will also come with less max RAM, but be unified?

Is the whole "unified" RAM a reason that the iMac and Mini are capped at 32G?

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by transitorykris on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:06PM (#41986695)
The Mac Studio has always had unified memory
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by kridsdale3 on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @01:45PM (#41987328)
All "Apple Silicon" products, going back to the first one, which was the iPhone 4.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by angoragoats on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:55PM (#41989304)
Fun fact: any PC with integrated graphics has also had unified memory (yep, including Intel Macs), for at least the past decade!
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by sliken on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @01:15AM (#41992106)
True, but PCs are 128 bits wide, apple lets you upgrade to 256 bits wide (M4 pro), 512 bits wide (m3 Max) or 1024 bits wide (M2 Ultra).

Unified memory is much more useful when you can get more bandwidth to it.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by fulafel on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @03:26AM (#41992579)
Yep, there's no performance x86 CPUs on the market with ambitious GPUs, only laptop chips. Games are optimized for discrete GPUs, Apple didn't have that software inertia to deal with.
Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by sliken on Wednesday October 30, 2024 @12:05PM (#41996709)
Sort of, obviously quite a few games are optimized for the PS5 and Xbox series X.

GPU cores are generally identical between the iGPUs and the discrete GPUs. Adding a PCIe bus (high latency and low bandwidth) and having a separate memory pool doesn't create new opportunities for optimization.

On the other hand having unified memory creates optimization opportunities, but even just making memcpy a noop can be useful as well.

Re:New Mac Mini with M4 by fulafel on Thursday October 31, 2024 @12:33AM (#42003531)
GPUs are all about (compute & memory) bandwidth. Using the same building blocks of compute units doesn't yet it go fast. You need a lot of compute units and a lot of bandwidth to feed them.

The performance dependency on DGPUs doesn't come from the existance of a PCIe bus and partitioned memory, but from the fact that the software running on the DGPU is written for a system with high bandwidth memory like GDDR6X or HBM. It creates opportunities for optimization the same way as hardware properties and machine balances tend to, the software gets written, benchmarked and optimized against hardware with certain kinds of performance properties and constraints (like here compute/bandwidth balance and memory capacity, and whether CPU & GPU have shared memory).