News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When are two proofs essentially the same? (2007) by lupire on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:40AM (#41985170)
A Proof is not a statement. A theorem is a statement.

Proofs are usually not completely formal or even formalizable. Math is not completely well founded. "Unravelling it all the way" might be an open research project, or a new conjecture directly inspired by the second, apparently different proof. Showing these two profs to be equivalent might depend on a major new idea that happens after the two proofs are createdm

This is hinted at in the OP discussion of Terry Tao.

Re:When are two proofs essentially the same? (2007) by bjornsing on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @11:49AM (#41985378)
> Proofs are usually not completely formal or even formalizable. Math is not completely well founded.

This is often stated, but is it really true? I haven’t seen a persuasive argument that not all math could (in principle) be formalized.