A language that's more productive gives you an O(n) benefit where n is the amount of work you do. Assuming you do a nontrivial amount of work, this is always going to outweigh the amount of time it takes to learn even the most difficult of languages.
Now, in a perfect world, a language would be both easy to learn and productive. Unfortunately, in practice, the most productive languages are also the most difficult to learn. However, this doesn't mean they shouldn't exist--quite the contrary even; I think they are more important than languages easy to learn but less productive.
Assuming you'll be spending any significant amount of time programming, don't pick a language exclusively because it is easy to learn!
This is why I find the "you can't find Ruby/Python/whatever developers" argument unconvincing. If you're a good software developer, you can learn new languages. You like learning new languages. It's only the crap developers who typecast themselves in one role throughout their career.
And while I don't believe in all the nonsense about ninja coders and only hiring the best of the best, really, the ability to learn a new imperative language is not a very high bar to clear.
The innovative ideas in programming language design are few and have been known for many years. Learning Ruby or Python instead of let's say Perl will bring you almost no benefits from a technical perspective.
You're essentially paying with your time to enter the Ruby&Rails ecosystem of jobs, consulting gigs, events and so on but you're still building websites using the same protocols, servers, databases, etc.
Language design, more than anything, seems to be a field where using actual academic research is passé. C# seems to be the one rare exception among the popular languages. On other platforms, the innovative ideas are all stuck in less popular languages like Scala, OCaml or Haskell.
I can't disagree more. PHP is as easy as any language should be. As if everyone implies the harder a language to use, the cooler it is.
In my understanding a smooth set up experience is a sign community cares about the thing. Extensive and up-to-date documentation means the community is large and not stagnating. A language easy to learn and use is a properly designed language. If the language is hard to understand and write code in, it should not exist at all.