When geneticists are studying eg., single-gene-to-single-disease relationships then this is science. When they're studying possible trajectories of 1000s of genes on down-stream phenomneon with an amazing number of uncontrollable causes.. then i'd be inclined to call this pseduoscience.
The line isn't arbitrary at all, but based on hard facts about the nature of reality and our ability to measure it.
Modelling the weather is a science if it is done based on extremely recent history, and the models are explanatory and accurate to within a relevant time horizon. If you use the same models to predict the weather next year, that's pseduoscience.
Pseudoscience is often deeply apparently scientific -- resuing all the same statsitical formulae, etc. -- this is a charade. It is reality which decides that these techniques are broken, not the techniques themselves.
Sure, and you’re welcome to have personal preferences. My point is just that “hard science” sounds like an objective term but it’s neither well-defined nor objective. Calling it “specialties which mjburgess likes” would be just meaningful.
So we're in a very very bad situation in these cases. It isnt that mere speculation is invovled as an input, its that mere speculation is the output.