> I agree it's inaccurate to say it's decided primarily by Foundations vs Analysis, but I'm not sure how else to slice the pie.
Seems you agree with me after all.
> I agree it's quibbling, but it's harder to teach maths to people if these False Friends exist but don't get pointed out.
A distribution is a function, but considered on a different space.
It is even harder to teach math to people by insisting that above fact is wrong. Schwartz got a Fields medal for this insight.
Terry Tao writes in his analysis book:
Functions are also referred to as maps or transformations, depending on the context.
Tao certainly knows more about this than I ever will.
You have 6 posts in the thread started by my top comment. I had multiple replies to one of your posts because HN requires one to wait a while to reply and I was in a hurry. The order of posts doesn’t matter. At least not to me.
Insinuating I’m obsessive has a negative connotation. Along with outright insults such comments make you look bad and unreasonable.
Functions are also referred to as maps or transformations, de- pending on the context.
This after defining a function in essentially the same I did.
> I see that you are desperately trying to distinguish "foundational" and "analysis" contexts from each other
They literally are different. The proof is all the people here saying that distributions aren't functions, while displaying a clear understanding of what a distribution is. Maybe no one's "wrong" as such, if they're defining the same word differently.
I think you're the naive one here. Terminology is used inconsistently, and I tried to simplify the dividing line between different uses of it. I agree it's inaccurate to say it's decided primarily by Foundations vs Analysis, but I'm not sure how else to slice the pie. It's like how the same word can mean slightly different things in French and English. I agree it's quibbling, but it's harder to teach maths to people if these False Friends exist but don't get pointed out.
I never expected some obsessive user to make 6 different replies to one of my comments. Wow. This whole thing thread was a bit silly, and someone's probably going to laugh at it. I need to take another break from this site.