News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gravity is not a force by TeMPOraL on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:44AM (#41972302)
I must be really confused about physics and reality, because that argument feels like an April Fools joke.

Stick a rocket engine to the side of the mountain, and light it up. An accelerometer glued to the mountain will show a 0. So will one glued to the rocket. Does that mean thrust is not a force now?

Re:Gravity is not a force by fnordpiglet on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:59AM (#41972552)
They will both show acceleration. The one on the mountain will show an upward acceleration from the mountain pushing against the device against the pull of gravity. The rocket would too, but presumably greater if it’s accelerating faster than gravity is pulling. The key is that the gravity acceleration vector never shows up in any context. That’s because it’s not a force and the perceived acceleration is an effect of relativity, caused by the gradient of time and space. It’s entirely counter intuitive to our understanding of force and acceleration that you can observe increasing relative motion without a force based acceleration, but there it is
Re:Gravity is not a force by stouset on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:55AM (#41972487)
F = ma, a = F/m.

In the scenario you’ve set up m >>>>>> F, because the Earth is fucking enormous. So a will be extremely small but nonzero. A precise enough accelerometer would show you this.

Also your mountain accelerometer would show ~9.8m/s^2 plus the extremely small contribution of the rocket thrust, not 0.

Re:Gravity is not a force by wrs on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:51AM (#41972430)
The accelerometer glued to the mountain will show -9.8m/s^2, not zero. The one glued to the rocket will show the same. The force of the rocket thrust is the opposite of the force of the glue holding it to the mountain, so the sum results in zero additional acceleration.
Re:Gravity is not a force by gorkish on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:52AM (#41972436)
> An accelerometer glued to the mountain will show a 0.

Incorrect. An accelerometer glued to the mountain will show -9.8m/s^2 because it's being accelerated by said mountain.

Re:Gravity is not a force by MichaelZuo on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:46AM (#41972334)
No?

A theoretically perfect accelerometer will show something non zero as the rocket engine is in fact shifting the entire Earth by a very very very very very very tiny amount.

Re:Gravity is not a force by TeMPOraL on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:51AM (#41972416)
Stick two identical rocket engines together in deep space so their thrust cancels out. Is thrust not a force when rockets' guidance accelerometers both show 0?
Re:Gravity is not a force by tsimionescu on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:54AM (#41972466)
But 0 is what you expect to see in that case: you have two forces acting on the body, of equal magnitude and in opposite directions, so the net force is 0, so acceleration is 0.

But if you jump out of a plane, you will see ~0. If gravity were a force, what would be the equal and opposite force acting on you?

Re:Gravity is not a force by wrs on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:54AM (#41972460)
Both engines are exerting force in opposite directions, which cancels out, as you said. There’s no acceleration happening either from gravity or this rocket arrangement, so the accelerometer reads zero. Why is this a problem? Who is saying thrust is not a force?
Re:Gravity is not a force by gorkish on Monday October 28, 2024 @11:55AM (#41972481)
If you are accelerating, the accelerometers will not "show 0". I have no idea where you are getting this notion from; it's completely wrong.
Re:Gravity is not a force by TeMPOraL on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:06PM (#41972650)
Accelerometers aren't magic. They don't read out True Acceleration from the process memory of the Matrix. There's a physical process inovlved, and that process cannot tell the rocket is accelerating when that acceleration is cancelled out.

Standing on the ground, the accelerometer should show zero because gravity is cancelled out by the floor being solid. If latter can be a force, why not the former?

Re:Gravity is not a force by wrs on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:13PM (#41972764)
I don’t know what else to tell you, the accelerometer in your phone is reading -9.8m/s^2 right now. Go get an app that reads your accelerometer and check it.
Re:Gravity is not a force by TeMPOraL on Monday October 28, 2024 @12:30PM (#41973029)
Accelerometer on my phone is reading f(a), not a. Unlike with e.g. old-school scales, there's layers of digital electronics and software between the measuring device and measurement being displayed. For all I know, if it's saying -9.8m/s^2, it may be because there's a `value = rawMeasurement - v3(0, 0, 9.81)` line somewhere in the code, because that's the value the designers wanted to report.

I mentioned old-school scales, truth be told, they do this thing too: they're measuring weight, but reporting it as mass, with 1/9.81 factor baked into the scale label directly.

Point being, I'm less interested in what some app tells me - you should always assume apps have assumptions and massage their numbers. I'm interested in whether the measuring device can actually tell the difference, which in case of forces perfectly cancelling out, it should not.

Re:Gravity is not a force by wrs on Monday October 28, 2024 @01:01PM (#41973422)
I assure you, because I’ve I’d done it, if you talk directly to the accelerometer, it will give you an XYZ acceleration vector with magnitude 9.8m/s^2 in the direction of the Earth (whichever way you turn it). Not because there is a magic “9.8” in the code, but because that’s what the acceleration is where you’re standing.

If you take the same accelerometer up a mountain, it will read a little less. In orbit, it will read zero. On the moon, it will read about 1.6.

Internally, sure, it does measure force. It measures the force being exerted by the teeny mounting structure to keep the teeny silicon weight in place. That force has to be exerted to counteract the acceleration of the gravity field and keep the weight from flying off. So that’s a straightforward way to measure acceleration. (To be super precise, it measures capacitance between the arms and the base, which is related to distance between them, which is related to force because the arms are flexible.)

Edit: Put another way, there actually is an adjustment in the code, because most people want the reading to be zero when the phone is not moving relative to the Earth. To accomplish that, you can’t just subtract a constant vector, you have to filter the output based on the assumption that there is always a large constant acceleration in some direction. If you rotate the phone, that vector will vary wildly in direction, and you have to pick out that signal and subtract it. This means accelerometers have to have a lot of dynamic range to accurately report that large acceleration added to the tiny ones you’re more interested in. In orbit, this wouldn’t be necessary.

Re:Gravity is not a force by taeric on Monday October 28, 2024 @04:23PM (#41975796)
The point is only that the accelerometer is measuring force. If you put your phone on a centrifuge long enough so that it reads a constant force going into it, you would be able to make a situation in deep space where it reads 9.8m/s in what feels like a constant direction to any human. Right? How would the accelerometer be able to detect that?
Re:Gravity is not a force by wrs on Monday October 28, 2024 @10:50PM (#41978887)
The accelerometer will read 9.8m/s^2 along the axis of the centrifuge, because that is the acceleration that is keeping the phone moving in a circle instead of flying into space.

The difference between that and resting the phone on the Earth is that the centrifuge structure is accelerating it by exerting force on it, whereas the Earth is accelerating it by altering the spacetime metric in its vicinity. Completely different mechanisms, same reading.

Re:Gravity is not a force by taeric on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @12:42AM (#41979444)
My point was the accelerometer would not be enough to expose what is happening. Imagine a centrifuge large enough that you can't determine the angle.
Re:Gravity is not a force by tsimionescu on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @04:52AM (#41981026)
You are actually wrong about the accelerometer, you're almost making the same error as the poster above.

The accelerometer shows 9.8m/s² IF you are holding it in your hand. And that acceleration is pointing up away from the earth, not down towards it. It is measuring the force of your hand/the table pushing it up to stop it from following its normal trajectory.

If you drop the accelerometer, it will show 0 until it hits the ground. If you're holding it while in a plain, it will show slightly less than 9.8, but if you drop it will still go down to 0. If you take it into space, it will show 0 even when it is touching your hand, because it's trajectory is no longer curved towards the center of the earth.

Re:Gravity is not a force by theamk on Monday October 28, 2024 @03:34PM (#41975174)
For cell phone, you don't need to trust the app much - it reports raw (X, Y, Z) vector. Turn the phone sideways and see how it's Z went to 0 and it's now Y (or X) showing -9.8. Spin in the chair and see how the vector's magnitude is increasing. This should be a pretty effective evidence that the vector is not offset, and at most scaled.
Re:Gravity is not a force by tsimionescu on Tuesday October 29, 2024 @05:01AM (#41981079)
> Standing on the ground, the accelerometer should show zero because gravity is cancelled out by the floor being solid. If latter can be a force, why not the former?

This is the part where you are demonstrably wrong. This experiment has actually been performed. Take an accelerometer that shows 0 in space far away from the Earth, where there is no gravity. Bring it back to the earth and let it fall from your ship: it will keep showing 0 (well, because of friction with air, it will show some value, but a pretty small one). When it reaches the ground, it will "suddenly" show 9.8m/s².

This is not something you can debate: this is the measured reality. You can debate how to explain this, of course. But the reality is there: being in freefall towards the earth is equivalent from an accelerometer point of view to being in deep space with no engines running.

Another similar observation is this: the feeling of being in a gravity well is not the earth pulling you down, it is the floor pushing you up. If you're on a space station in deep space, to feel the same as on the earth, you need something pushing at your feet in the direction of your head, not something pushing on your head in the direction of your feet.