Re:Saturated fat: the making and unmaking of a scientific co...
by KempyKolibri on Sunday October 27, 2024 @11:39AM
(#41963360)
> for cvd risk mortality if you exclude the largest single study that also had a long duration (WHI 2006) it made CVD risk mortality significant, so one of those long duration studies is dragging the results the opposite way.
Right, and the proposed pathway by which SFA increases CVD risk is via increases in ApoB/LDL-c. What LDL-c differences did they achieve in WHI 2006?
If you want to claim that 15 more incidents per 1000 of a disease that is one of the top killers in the western world is a rounding error, then go for it. I don’t think that’s a reasonable position, personally.
As for the speculation about higher levels being healthy - speculate away, but I don’t see why anyone should believe it’s the case when
a) it runs contrary to the body of evidence on the subject
b) there’s no actual evidence backing up that speculation.
Right, and the proposed pathway by which SFA increases CVD risk is via increases in ApoB/LDL-c. What LDL-c differences did they achieve in WHI 2006?
If you want to claim that 15 more incidents per 1000 of a disease that is one of the top killers in the western world is a rounding error, then go for it. I don’t think that’s a reasonable position, personally.
As for the speculation about higher levels being healthy - speculate away, but I don’t see why anyone should believe it’s the case when a) it runs contrary to the body of evidence on the subject b) there’s no actual evidence backing up that speculation.