News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by openrisk on Saturday October 26, 2024 @05:49AM (#41953734)
It is interesting that nobody comments on the "ownership" data point of the post.

> And guess who just bought a seat on BlueSky's board with a $15M Series A round?

Yet that is the only thing that matters.

The technical pieces for a vast range of alternative designs for online interactions are already available. Decentralized, federated, distributed, peer-to-peer. Who cares? What matters is the outcome.

What is entirely missing in these silly "protocol wars" is any concrete and realistic vision of what that "good next generation Web" looks like, not technically, but economically, socially and politically. Who gets empowered and who gets exploited. Who gets (and how strong) a voice and who gets manipulated by that voice.

The prior norms, social contracts and institutions we used to have in the pre-digital era have been completely corrupted yet there is no visible replacement beyond some vague ideals.

The shape of the "next gen web" very much depends on who funds it, why (what incentives and expectations do they have) and how (what incentives and expectations do they create to the vast ecosystems of developers, entrepreneurs, moderators, users, etc).

Re:Bluesky Is Not Decentralized by alexch on Monday October 28, 2024 @09:46AM (#41970964)
YES. i’m the OP. The point of the post was to avoid bickering about the technical in-context contradictory ambiguous definitions of “centralized” and “algorithm” and to point to the root issue: concentration vs dilution of *human power*.

How many points of failure are there? Who is in control of them? How many Elons would it take to screw the whole thing up for everybody?

the core fact is that #Bluesky is owned by goblins who are totally (probably) gonna push it down the #enshitification path no matter what its network topology looks like.

(goblin owners including the actual guy who fucked up Twitter and then sold it to the second worst person on the planet)

I wish ATProto was a proper old-school open standard, since there’s a lot of cool ideas in it, and some well-intentioned dedicated hobbyists building a community around it, but it’s still mostly a wishful-thinking stalking-horse for a single company and their greedy #utilitopian owners.

the details of the network topology are important, but ultimately a red herring

what we’re talking about is concentration of control

it’s all about power

who gets to call the shots, for whom, with whose consent, for whose benefit

and power corrupts

don’t trust the scorpion

and there’s a lot of really smart, really well intentioned people working at BlueSky, and on ATProtocol… but as the old saying goes:

*the road to hell is paved with good intentions*

(as i said in a later entry in the thread — which of course nobody bothered to read, since they got stuck playing Dictionary Fallacy with the word “algorithm”, see https://beige.party/@possibledog/113379279962049131 )

maybe the term “centralize” is too physical a metaphor for this abstract debate, since it implies a radial axis, along which the opposite of central is decentral, but that’s not how social networks work: there are always many centers