News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by ahnick on Friday October 25, 2024 @04:49PM (#41949603)
It seems like it would be less polarizing if it was the default state for news and information outlets to not endorse any candidate ever and just remain as neutral as possible.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by oivey on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:09PM (#41950828)
Why would they want to appear neutral? All news reporting, no matter what, is inherently biased in some way. There isn’t some “ideal” where that isn’t the case. There can’t be some magical font of unbiased information because just selecting what stories to put on the front page introduces bias.

News can’t be unbiased and being unbiased was never a goal. News is meant to inform, which includes facts as well as analysis. That seemingly the average American doesn’t understand that is a failure of the education system.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by roenxi on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:19PM (#41950905)
Sure. But the newspaper could be biased towards facts, moderate speech and empathy to all parties. Then - despite being biased - people wouldn't be as worried about bias.

People are misusing the word "unbiased" but I don't think there is much uncertainty about what they actually mean - the call is for less partisan bias and more bias towards, say, enlightenment values. The exact values are a political topic but reporting with any values at all would be a step up for the US corporate media.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by oivey on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:36PM (#41951058)
That’s fair enough, but you should consider that a news source might be biased toward facts and empathy and still might endorse a candidate.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by FactKnower69 on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:15PM (#41951687)
>But the newspaper could be biased towards facts, moderate speech and empathy to all parties.

literally zero semantic meaning to be found in this word salad

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by user3939382 on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:20PM (#41950907)
You’re suggesting there’s no difference between journalism that attempts objectivity and outright political advocacy which is clearly false. Perfect neutrality doesn’t exist, we can even get into a discussion of what knowledge is, that doesn’t mean news outlets don’t have an obligation to try. They did in decades past which is evident from a review of older journalism.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by oivey on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:31PM (#41951021)
What older journalism are you talking about? Cold War era Cronkite? The era of endless red scares and other very obviously biased behavior?

WaPo has been giving out endorsements since the 70s. The era you’re pining for never existed.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by bigstrat2003 on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:30PM (#41951007)
That just isn't true. It is possible to be unbiased in journalism, and it was a major goal of journalists at various times in history. Obviously not all journalists at all times have striven towards this goal, but some have. Stop making excuses for blatant partisanship, instead hold them to a higher standard.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by t-writescode on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:43PM (#41951128)
> "to be unbiased in journalism"

By no means. Word choice on its own __is__ a bias. Even if you reported straight facts, the word choice used presents a bias or not. Is it a military action or a terrorist attack? Is it a protest? An occupation? Are they Freedom Fighters?

Choosing __to__ or __not to__ use an organization's given name or a description of them, is having a bias.

Choosing to report on something at all is a presentation of bias.

There is bias in everything and to imagine there isn't is to be even more susceptible to it.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by lucb1e on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:45PM (#41951821)
> Why would they want to appear neutral? [...] There isn’t some “ideal”

Getting some notion of what USA politics are like on HN, I can understand why you'd have this viewpoint, but I don't think it's true

The news I am used to, I couldn't tell you what political color it has. The selection they make seems based on the perceived severity, which certainly means there is a selection process that must be introducing some sort of bias, but as near as I can tell, this bias is towards a shared humanity and not a party

Perhaps I am just naïve, so I opened the local Wikipedia and it has no mention of them being accused of having a bias, political coloring or selection, notable omissions, or any such thing

I disagree strongly with the party for hate and egocentricity having come out as the biggest one in the most recent election, and to a lesser extent with the rich people be rich party from the previous ~decade, so it's not like all noses are pointed in the same direction where I'm from; but I couldn't tell you how this organization (the default thing if you turn on your TV at prime time) feels about any particular party beyond that I expect they would condemn hate and violence in general -- shared humanity, basically.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by refurb on Saturday October 26, 2024 @12:18AM (#41952518)
> Why would they want to appear neutral? All news reporting, no matter what, is inherently biased in some way. There isn’t some “ideal” where that isn’t the case. There can’t be some magical font of unbiased information because just selecting what stories to put on the front page introduces bias.

Sure, but just because you can't be perfectly unbiased doesn't mean the only alternative is to become a mouthpiece for a political party.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by mint2 on Saturday October 26, 2024 @01:31AM (#41952766)
That pretentious “above the fray” belief some news orgs and reporters have is awful and harmful.

NYT is particularly guilty of that behavior.

How one contextualizes a story and presents the attention grabbing headline puts a massive thumb on the scale of how the topic is perceived.

Because of what the article mentions or doesn’t mention, provides context for or no context for, the exact same core story centerpiece is biased and leading. Any impression the author wants to convey is easy to bring out in the “neutral” writing. This is simply a fact of writing.

And yet some reporters and news orgs, like the NYT, profess they are neutral observers as if from the planet zorg recording a miraculous unbiased story.

No, that is impossible and everyone knows it. Claiming to be neutral is gas lighting.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by coreload on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:03PM (#41950776)
These are opinion editors. They're expected to have opinions.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by 93po on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:11PM (#41950838)
maybe biased opinions should be entirely separate from journalistic enterprises if those journalists want a single shred of credibility. people are mad at trump supporters and anti covid and anti vax stuff, and while i agree that's all stupid, i don't blame them at all for falling for it because main stream corporate journalism has destroyed any and all trust with absolutely everyone. maybe if we weren't constantly being lied to and sold something, more people would believe them when they say important things like "trump is taking away reproductive rights" and "covid exists and people are dying"
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by makeitdouble on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:52PM (#41951209)
Journalistic credibility comes from presenting facts. Which facts you present, which pieces you publish are in themselves opinions, biases.

That's why I see aiming for unbiased reporting to miss the point of journalism. We want opinions, but not random uneducated opinions, we want well argumented, relevant and proof backed opinions.

"Candidate X is a liar" is valid journalism if there's the facts to back the claim and the analysis to make it a thought provoking piece that brought something to the readers. We have whole Pullitzer winning books going into minute details about how some public figures are crooks.

To note, not reporting, not expressing opinions is also a bias so I don't see a middle ground. For instance if a major national journalism would not publish the news of a candidate getting arrested, that in itself is a biased decision. If they'd publish a dry piece just quoting the official police declaration, that would also be tremendous bias and everyone would see it as a refusal to comment on it.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by nkrisc on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:16PM (#41950876)
Pretending there exists “unbiased” journalism is silly. All journalism is biased to some degree. The worthwhile categorization is to what degree the bias exists.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by EasyMark on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:42PM (#41951118)
And how well they use facts to back their bias(es)
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by ajross on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:13PM (#41950850)
That's a fair point. But in this case it wasn't a principled stand against the idea of opinion journalism[1]. It was an act to kill an in-progress editorial piece days before publication, for quite clearly partisan reasons (though most people believe Bezos did it out of fear and not affinity, he'd presumably prefer Trump loses, but doesn't want to be in the line of fire if he doesn't).

[1] Which, let's be honest, is pervasive and popular. You aren't simultaneously arguing to kick Hannity off the air, right?

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by neves on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:54PM (#41950681)
First, they are never neutral.

Second: this is what happens in Brazil. Everybody gets angry because each news outlet defends its own conservative candidate.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by drukenemo on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:11PM (#41950842)
Are you saying that the largest media complex in Brazil, Globo, supports conservative candidates? Where and how?
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by zztop44 on Friday October 25, 2024 @08:43PM (#41951540)
Is this sarcasm? Globo has never missed an opportunity to be virulently anti-PT.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by ribosometronome on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:23PM (#41950945)
But it is not. They regularly make endorsements and call outs. They recently called for Biden to step down from the ticket, just months ago. It seems like we should not examine situations based on idealistic, non-existent scenarios but the world we actually live in.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by mschuster91 on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:24PM (#41950952)
News outlets by definition can not be neutral. Just look at the insane amount of stuff that the global news agencies like Reuters or AFP push out every minute, and on top of that comes all the state, county and local news.

The very act of filtering what to report to the audience is political in itself. Say, floods or other natural disasters caused or (like wildfires) made worse by climate change. Most of them tend to be ignored outside of the nation they happen, but not reporting on it also means that people don't grasp just how bad climate change already is, and thus the people may not vote for parties or individuals campaigning on climate change.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by megous on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:51PM (#41951204)
You learn this by science, and scientific reporting. Not by reporting events usually selected by severity of harm to humans and clickbait factor to enrich the media companies.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by metabagel on Saturday October 26, 2024 @01:58AM (#41952884)
I feel like you missed the point, which is that reporting or not reporting, or how you report something can all be examples of bias. The conclusions you draw. The quotes you use or don’t use. The ordering in which you report things.

The job of the journalist is to try to present a version of the story which is as close to the truth as possible, and without leaving out any relevant information. But, also the story is in context of the values which most of us hold dear, because we are human beings.

We might have thought that an unbiased news story would have to be written by a robot, but as we know now, LLMs are biased too.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by Eumenes on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:18PM (#41950894)
100%. People upset about this are just upset cause they didn't endorse their candidate. Trust in media/journalism is at an all time low. This is simply a smart move to not alienate 50% of the population. If individual editors/writers/journalists want to endorse someone, take it to your blog or website or twitter.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:21PM (#41950919)
Being neutral in the face of a candidate who has promised to do what Trump has promised to do may not be the virtue you think it is.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by lucb1e on Friday October 25, 2024 @09:22PM (#41951714)
I would read "neutral" here to mean "factual" rather than endorsing trump as part of being neutral or something. If one party proposes e.g. impossible things or financially stupid things or whatever it may be (general examples from politics anywhere), that can and should be reported on and would not break neutrality
[dead]
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by bydo on Friday October 25, 2024 @05:42PM (#41950096)
The Washington Post has endorsed a candidate every election cycle since 1976, with the exception of 1988. The New York Times has endorsed a candidate in every presidential election since its founding in 1851.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by smeeger on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:03PM (#41950777)
yes. its always been done and therefore is good! …?
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by arp242 on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:36PM (#41951068)
What was said was: "In the 90s newspapers made an effort to not endorse candidates to appear unbiased".

This was countered with "endorsements have been a thing since long before the 90s".

Previous poster didn't say anything about what's "good" or "bad". They pointed out a claim was incorrect.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by goostavos on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:50PM (#41950649)
Just because it has always been done doesn't make it good.

It's surprising to me that a news organization not publishing an opinion piece is itself giant front page news

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by newswasboring on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:04PM (#41950792)
What's so bad about large institutions in the opinion shaping space endorsing?
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by goostavos on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:21PM (#41950918)
Nothing, I suppose. I honestly didn't realize it's so contentious. I guess it just seemed kind of weird for "the news" to have an opinion at all. Why do people want an organization to tell them who they think should be president?
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by nobodyandproud on Friday October 25, 2024 @05:09PM (#41949803)
I definitely remember the 1990s differently.

They still had endorsements, but it just wasn’t spelled out that way.

Instead, just prominent opinions, hit pieces, etc.

Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by iwontberude on Friday October 25, 2024 @06:52PM (#41950669)
I do remember the 1990s where it was typically local newspapers doing explicit endorsements and it was almost always limited to local candidates and issues.
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by nektro on Friday October 25, 2024 @07:04PM (#41950789)
no endorsement is an endorsement for the oppressor
Re:Jeff Bezos killed Washington Post endorsement of Kamala H... by w0de0 on Saturday October 26, 2024 @02:15AM (#41952938)
While we’re at it, let’s do away with voting. Much less polarizing if we stop asking the demos to endorse a government.