Re:With Kickstarter, Who Needs the National Endowment for th...
by jerf on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:54PM
(#4194943)
So, we can't judge art by whether it's popular, we can't judge it by whether it's aesthetic, we can't judge it by X... at what point does the NEA simply become indistinguishable from handing money to whomever it wants for whatever reason it wants as long as the recipient does something or other?
This is the government. Men with guns come and take bits of my life that I have traded for money away to fund this. If you're willing to go to that length, I'd appreciate some sort of metric whereby the NEA can tell whether or not they're even getting anything for their money, let alone whether it's worth it. I know it's really tempting to just deny any metric of worth can be applied to art, but if you nail art down to the point where only .01% of the population can appreciate it and we have to fund it because the plebians won't.... where's the public interest in this?
(Also, I'm not claiming the NEA has no such standards. Actually I quite believe it does, and in the end those standards are what people actually object to. I'm saying that it isn't viable to continuously keep falling back, saying "No, that's not what art is, no, that's not what art is, no, that's not what art is". This is something taxpayers are funding with their sweat and blood... if they aren't getting anything that can even be vaguely defined without someone challenging that vague definition, then it should just be shut down.)
This is the government. Men with guns come and take bits of my life that I have traded for money away to fund this. If you're willing to go to that length, I'd appreciate some sort of metric whereby the NEA can tell whether or not they're even getting anything for their money, let alone whether it's worth it. I know it's really tempting to just deny any metric of worth can be applied to art, but if you nail art down to the point where only .01% of the population can appreciate it and we have to fund it because the plebians won't.... where's the public interest in this?
(Also, I'm not claiming the NEA has no such standards. Actually I quite believe it does, and in the end those standards are what people actually object to. I'm saying that it isn't viable to continuously keep falling back, saying "No, that's not what art is, no, that's not what art is, no, that's not what art is". This is something taxpayers are funding with their sweat and blood... if they aren't getting anything that can even be vaguely defined without someone challenging that vague definition, then it should just be shut down.)