News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Starting a Startup by davidw on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @10:24AM (#4194185)
Without saying whether it's a good solution or not, in the real world "properties" (as some people have taken to calling web sites) get taxed. Amongst other things, this encourages the property owners to "shit or get off the pot" in terms of utilizing the property: if you are not making anything off of it, you will actually lose money because of the taxes, so you're encouraged to sell it, or dedicate some time and effort to fix it up to a point where you can rent it out or otherwise gainfully employ it.

With domain names, there is a fixed yearly "tax" of something like $10.

There are a lot of things to dislike about property taxes on domain names, but it would be one way of encouraging people to either do something or let them go, which hopefully would encourage them to end up where they are most 'productively' employed.

Re:On Starting a Startup by tjic on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:08PM (#4194675)
> this encourages the property owners to "shit or get off the pot" in terms of utilizing the property:

And why is that good?

Imagine that someone has good reason to believe that item X will be worth $1,000 in three years, which means that in a 3% interest rate regime it has a NPV (Net Present Value) of $915.

Right now he's got an offer on the table for $800, but if he accepts that and the resource gets used up, he (and society) lose out on $115 of value.

Slap a 10% annual tax on the asset, and he WILL sell it, right now.

...and, congratulations, you've destroyed value.

Re:On Starting a Startup by crazygringo on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:21PM (#4195090)
What about the value that someone else could created by using that property productively over those three years? And the likelihood that, three years from now, item X turns out not to be worth $1,000 at all?

Then that value has been destroyed in your scenario.

This is why property tax can be a good thing: set properly, it creates an incentive for conserving property for future productive uses when those seem likely enough, but also incentivizes people not to waste current possible productivity.

Re:On Starting a Startup by mindcrime on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @10:29AM (#4194205)
if you are not making anything off of it, you will actually lose money because of the taxes, so you're encouraged to sell it, or dedicate some time and effort to fix it up to a point where you can rent it out or otherwise gainfully employ it.

This sounds like an argument for ending property tax, not an argument for adding a "web property tax."

Re:On Starting a Startup by davidw on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @10:32AM (#4194223)
Property is a scarce resource. It's not nice if someone has a huge building downtown and just lets it rot, because that has negative externalities for other people in the area.

To me, encouraging property - especially the commercial sort - to go to its most productive use (or at least some productive use) makes sense. Whether property taxes are the most efficient mechanism is a pretty broad and complex debate; I was just suggesting one idea that may or may not work. Personally, I think I'd be against a web-domain tax, but it bears thinking about.