News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by joe_the_user on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:16AM (#4192641)
As I recall, Nokia started the war by demanding either an exorbitant price for their FRAND patents from Apple or the right to cross-license Apple's UI patents.

I don't see Apple in any way morally superior here. It is as if a country came to a summit and said "I see you have a nice arms control treaty. I want to join - except I won't be including this weapon, with which I'm going to immediately attack you".

Because FRAND was a way to avoid mutually assured destruction. With Apple finding away to start an attack separately, one can hardly say "hey, they were taking the high ground here".

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by taligent on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @03:14AM (#4192923)
That's not correct.

FRAND was a way to ensure that a standard had the ability to become popular without patents getting in the way. Cross licensing is about avoid mutually assured destruction.

The idea that Apple got an injunction for a patent dispute is hardly unique. It happens all the time.

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by ajross on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:54PM (#4194944)
It certainly doesn't happen "all the time". You have other examples of the import of mainstream tech gadgets being enjoined outside the current patent mess? Has it ever happened to a PC?