News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by thechut on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @12:46AM (#4192570)
Everybody is saying that these are all FRAND patents but that is simply not true. Yes some of the patents in question are related to UTMS. However, Samsung also has other patent claims including:

-"A method for dialing a phone number in a smart phone having both PDA (Personal Digital Assistant) and mobile phone functions"[1] - The ability to click a number and call it

-"A method and device for reproducing digital audio data in a mobile station is disclosed."[2] - MP3 playback

-" The system code can process an input byte stream that is representative of contents to be displayed on the touch sensitive display and can generate a content document file representative of an internal representation of the content."[3] - Seems like view panning essentially

These are the exact same type of patents that Apple alleges infringement by Samsung.

-"A computer-implemented method for use in conjunction with a computing device with a touch screen display comprises: detecting one or more finger contacts with the touch screen display, applying one or more heuristics to the one or more finger contacts to determine a command for the device, and processing the command." [4] - the touch screen patent

-"Plug detection mechanisms can be provided for detecting when a plug of an accessory component is present within a jack of an electronic device."[5] - Headphone detection

These is by no means all of them, just an example of how both sides are basically doing the same to each other.

None of these patents are extraordinary features, they are the technologies we take for granted in modern smartphones. At best, these patent wars don't help anybody but the lawyers involved. At the worst, either of these companies could crush a startup using what are pretty ubiquitous technologies just because they have a loosely worded patent.

It's not about one side looking worse than the other, this is an all out war and these companies will do whatever is necessary to keep their hard worked on products on the market.

Perhaps Apple fans do a better job of spreading smut about who is suing who for what, so you say "Google is losing the PR war about their integrity"

But really we are all losing when it comes to innovation and competition. FRAND policies are useless. It's time to reform software and hardware patents and expand fair use.

edited for spacing.

[1]: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec... [2]: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec... [3]: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec... [4]: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec... [5]: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sec...

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by taligent on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:09AM (#4192623)
Let's get a few things very, very clear here.

1) Apple has NOT used FRAND patents against Android OEMs.

2) The FTC/EU are not investigating Apple for anti-competitive behaviour.

So it is irrelevant what 'normal' patents you bring up. The FACT is that the only ones acting disgracefully here are HTC, Samsung and Google.

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by makomk on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @05:12AM (#4193226)
The reason Apple hasn't used FRAND patents against Android OEMs is because it doesn't have any FRAND patents it could use. The reason it doesn't have them is because, unlike its competitors, Apple didn't fund the fundamental R&D on which modern mobile phone networks are based. Apple basically wants to be able to take the fruits of its competitors R&D that made smartphones possible for cents whilst locking those competitors out of making money from selling their own phones via patents on trivial things like slide-to-unlock and detecting phone numbers in messages.
Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by _djo_ on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @05:50AM (#4193301)
This is untrue, Apple does have FRAND patents. The ZeroConf patents (4,661,902 and 4,689,786) are just two examples. However Apple has always made those patents available under FRAND terms. For instance this was its statement with regards to its intellectual property rights contained within one of the draft IETF networking standards:

In the event that the technology discussed in the Document becomes an IETF standard (the "Standard") which is not materially different from the Document, Apple agrees, upon written request from a Party to negotiate outside of IETF to make available a non-exclusive license under reasonable and non-discriminatory ("RAND") terms and conditions under such claims of the Patents that are essential to implement a product compliant with the Standard (a "Compliant Product"). These RAND terms and conditions may be conditional upon a reciprocal grant or defense use. [1]

While I am unimpressed by the current patent war, the unnecessary injunctions and Apple's suits, I believe that the abuse of FRAND patents by Motorola Mobility, Samsung and, by proxy, Google are threatening to undermine the entire basis of FRAND patents which could have severe consequences in future.

[1]http://datatracker.ietf.org/ipr/420/

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by thechut on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @01:21AM (#4192657)
1) My point was not that Apple used FRAND patents against Android OEMs but that not all patents used by Android OEMs against Apple are FRAND patents.

2) Not sure how this is related but they probably should be

Samsung is asking for a few more percentage points on royalties, Apple has sought (and succeeded) to outright ban the import and sale of Samsung products in multiple countries. Which one of those sounds more disgraceful and anti-competitive to you?

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by czr80 on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @02:50AM (#4192871)
I'm mystified why you think 1) matters in this argument. Obviously this is a very different discussion if they dropped the FRAND patent suits and only sued on non-FRAND patents.

And, since you ask, I think threatening the entire industry standard (which affects every single company that implements the standards) is much, much worse than any action between two companies. They have enough money to sort it out themselves.

Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by fpgeek on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @12:10AM (#4197551)
Personally, I think promoting and legitimizing (from a technology company, not a non-practicing entity) the use of garbage software patents as a legal tool (and, even worse, an injunction-producing legal tool) has the potential to do far worse damage to the software industry in the long run.
Re:Google joins Samsung in patent dispute with Apple by taligent on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @03:11AM (#4192919)
Apple's behaviour only affects Apple and Samsung.

Samsung's behaviour has ramifications for entire industries.