Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by wtvanhest on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:30PM
(#4191126)
30% chance of rain actually means 30% of the area is projected to have rain covering it rather than there being a 30% chance you will be rained on.
An unlikely, but theoretically possible way to get 50% inside of 15 minute interval but 20% over an hour would be if the model prodicted very widespread rain in a band moving over an area and time weighted the percentage.
Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by mhurron on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @07:44AM
(#4193602)
> 30% chance of rain actually means 30% of the area is projected to have rain covering it
Common misconception. The Chance of precipitation is actually stating that historically, given these conditions x% of days produced precipitation. It is a statement of the odds that it will rain at all.
http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/854/what-does-it-me...
Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by wtvanhest on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @08:51AM
(#4193809)
That site you provide (or cite) is the only one I can find that describes it that way. Every other source describes the otherway which I still think is correct:
NOAA: http://www.srh.noaa.gov/ffc/?n=pop
http://www.usatoday.com/weather/resources/askjack/wadefine.h...
Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by mhurron on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @09:29AM
(#4193951)
Even those links state the PoP is a measure of the chance that it will happen at all. That is the historical measurement.
Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by wtvanhest on Tuesday July 03, 2012 @09:55AM
(#4194065)
No, that is the simplified explanation of how the average person should think about it. We are talking about the definition and a possible way to get the odd results the OP mentioned observing.
Re:Wunderground.com sold to The Weather Channel Companies
by mertd on Monday July 02, 2012 @05:22PM
(#4191089)
Purely speculating, but it may be the expected duration of rain. So 30% in one hour means on the average it will rain 18 minutes within that hour and 50% of 15 mins would be 7.5 rainy minutes.
My real guess is that they have independent models for different time resolutions.
Not to mention that their forecasts are presented in a way that is statistically incoherent. Look at their hourly forecasts, then click to break down by 15 minute intervals. It is common to see things like "rain during 2:00-3:00 = 30%", and then also have something like 50% during one of the 15 minute intervals within that time range. I have yet to come up with a hypothesis for what those percentages could mean, and have that scenario be possible.