News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by legitster on Monday October 21, 2024 @02:34PM (#41907002)
This may be one of the most pretentious things I have ever read. But on the other hand, it gives us these amazingly un-self aware sentences like these:

> Each of these changes influenced the broader social-network characteristics in ways that are not yet fully understood, quantitatively, but which entailed a shift in the user experience that we colloquially refer to as “vibes.”

> In addition, the significantly greater declines in engagement among more popular accounts were consistent with a reputational driver, wherein scholars with larger profiles may have been more concerned about being perceived as tacitly endorsing the platform.

You know, I've seen a fair share now of academics using academia to complain about the state of Twitter. But I have yet to see one that actually compared the quality of academic output of Twitter users vs non-Twitter users. To quote this article:

> Twitter is a social network where academics can feel seen by their peers, learn in-group signifiers, and express themselves in ways that produce positive feelings of solidarity (Jünger and Fähnrich Reference Jünger and Fähnrich2020). In this sense, the academic Twitter community operates according to the same psychological incentives as any other online community (Bail Reference Bail 2021)

Was Twitter manufacturing the feeling of an "insiders" group actually a good thing? In nearly every other community it seems to generate confirmation bias and groupthink.

You'd think this would be an easy thing to quantify - did academics who used Twitter actually produce more or better quality work?

Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by drjasonharrison on Monday October 21, 2024 @04:10PM (#41908021)
You might be missing the fact that members of "echo chamber" like communities often do not have discourse on their viewpoints outside of their echo chambers. Truthfully few people do, because that isn't as much fun as "fighting the good fight" and experiencing feelings of membership.

While communities are prone to confirmation bias and groupthink, or "echo chambers" they also reinforce social norms, provide feedback on statements, and connect people. This is not restricted to online social networks. University communities have people who "think different". Often this leads to wider perspectives, more meta-level discussions, and more historically informed viewpoints.

University communities however may not include marginalized experiences, "man on the street" opinions, or "what do the unwashed think." Though this is somewhat less likely as academics do spend time outside of the university grounds like other members of the surrounding population and are exposed to other people and their ideas.

Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by liveoneggs on Monday October 21, 2024 @03:03PM (#41907279)
> feel seen by their peers, learn in-group signifiers

Especially gross for academics

Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by wormius on Monday October 21, 2024 @03:16PM (#41907405)
Your comment itself, is, of course an "in-group signifier". But I guess if you're not an academic it's less gross? Or if you are an academic, you're virtue signaling how "not an in-group signifier" you are by "out-of-group" signaling. Or something.

I'm not really meaning to attack you, even though it sounds like it - but just noting a certain irony of judgement about in-group signifiers without acknowledging that one is always signifiying.

One cannot escape signification. And to judge it as something to be avoided (as opposed to observed and noted), is... well... IDK. No man is an island and all that. Even stones cannot escape being signified, but they are incapable of signifying. Humans on the other hand. Cannot even escape the process of doing the signifiying. There is no "gross" as it is a social phenomenon and all ingroup/outgroup dynamics always hold, and all such organizational referents happen across the domains, regardless, and no-one is above this, no matter how much we wish to absolve ourselves of this process.

And that was a hell of a signifier, on my part. (one signifying I'm a wannabe academic with no actual formal education, I suppose).

EDIT: Further - what exactly do you think the point of Academics is? To get published, and how do you get published? Via RECOGNITION OF PEERS. So this fits fully hand in glove with entirely WHAT academia is. Academia is a social function, it is not a sterile lab with pure physics and escaped from the social dimension.

I guess I am critiquing you, despite what I said earlier, as I've thought about it more, and think - this sounds very much like something someone who works in a pristine 'logical' domain of computing thinks academia should be, not what it is. It further reinforces the fact that comp-sci people SHOULD take social sciences to understand such things, and it also explains why Elon is such a shit lord cuz he thinks the greats like Norbert Wiener and other systems theorists were abstracted away from society, when they knew full well just how integrated society is in everything.

Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by liveoneggs on Tuesday October 22, 2024 @11:29AM (#41915261)
Hopefully my account here is not tied to my IRL identity in any meaningful way. I can signal this or that but it offers no upside to my life, unlike people using platforms like twitter to elevate their "brand".

My opinion expanded:

It's gross for academics to create in-group echo chambers because they are supposed to be exploring new things, or reproducing novel things, or otherwise expanding our world.

The social dynamics in-play for getting work published, cited, and elevated are, in my view, a corruption. It's obvious charismatic and connected people/institutions corrupt the publishing system (so practical science in general), distorting research, and causing real harm in the world at large.

Academic influencers are no different than other social media influencers but their reach into the serious real world of consequences is more real.

https://www.acs.org/pressroom/reactions/library/alzheimers-r...

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1497700/

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...

https://www.apa.org/monitor/2021/09/career-research-miscondu...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis

Re:The Vibes Are Off: Did Elon Musk Push Academics Off Twitter? by andriesm on Monday October 21, 2024 @10:18PM (#41910556)
I also found the scientific-ness of the term "Vibes" sprinkled throughout hillarious.

And the article plays back and forth with it's own claims, one momeng saying it will answer the question then saying later it is yet to be determined and then again saying it will quantify it...

Got quite deep into it, but had to give up along the way.

It was somewhat fun to read but could not get what was the point they wanted to make, other than play what appears to be very self indulgent word games. Maybe this is what is required of academic writing nowadays?