Re:Jujutsu (jj), a Git compatible VCS
by edflsafoiewq on Sunday October 20, 2024 @07:49PM
(#41899492)
Stashing vs WIP commits have pros and cons. I've never hit any of these problems you're pointing out, so I don't have any particular strong opinion about which one you should use.
I can see that being nice I guess.
If jj's stashes are just regular commits, don't you have the problem where you accidentally push a stash just like you push a WIP commit?
It’s not like these are git’s only pain points. Git is practically the poster child for software that’s difficult and confusing to use.
Re:Jujutsu (jj), a Git compatible VCS
by edflsafoiewq on Sunday October 20, 2024 @08:03PM
(#41899547)
I don't think so. Like the OP, my everyday git usage is pretty straightforward. So "maybe this thing you do every once in a while could be a little nicer" doesn't feel very compelling.
Re:Jujutsu (jj), a Git compatible VCS
by steveklabnik on Monday October 21, 2024 @12:24PM
(#41905747)
> don't you have the problem where you accidentally push a stash just like you push a WIP commit?
Because jj doesn’t require commits to be on a branch, and the equivalent feature (bookmarks) don’t automatically advance, if you created a new commit to stash some stuff, the name wouldn’t move to it, and so when you push nothing would happen.
jj needs neither because everything in your working copy is already part of a commit. You can’t accidentally push unfinished changes because jj will complain if it hasn’t been described (given a commit message). If you need to move changes between commits you don’t need to stash because you can easily move the contents of a commit around.