News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Syncthing Android App Discontinued by refulgentis on Sunday October 20, 2024 @03:50PM (#41898011)
> (snarky response)

If you are now claiming your question was rhetorical, it doesn't mean that when answered, it is snark.

> It's easy to bash someone

No one's being bashed. Lets put it in stark relief. Here's the bashing you replied to: "But that's really hard to do if you didn't begin with cross platform architecture that doesn't take into account having to modularize the filesystem layer for Android/iOS :/"

> The change is absolutely arbitrary

No, it isn't.

We can tell you know that, because you immediately say "There used to be no way to grant apps access to specific folders."

> But now

"Now" == "3 years ago"

> demanding people who don't even work for them to rewrite their projects

They're not demanding anything, other than Google can't keep taking updates to an app with full filesystem access 3 years later unless they patch the filesystem access. As other comments note, there's plenty of storefronts for these situations. (n.b. it's dangerous to take updates with unpatched security flaws, because bad actors buy apps/browser extensions)

> But blocking older apps, that were written when there literally wasn't an alternative available, to do a full rewrite or be banned from updating

Though interpretative charity, I'm guessing you mean they can't push updates, unless an update includes stopping asking for full filesystem access with 0 alternatives.

> to do a full rewrite

No ones demanding this

There are no comments on this comment yet.