Re:Language is not essential for the cognitive processes tha...
by GoblinSlayer on Sunday October 20, 2024 @06:33AM
(#41894429)
If brain isn't more special than Chinese room, then brain understands Chinese no better than Chinese room?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Language is not essential for the cognitive processes tha...
by mannykannot on Sunday October 20, 2024 @09:29AM
(#41895247)
The brain is faster than the Chinese room, but other than that, yes, that's the so-called systems reply; Searle's response to it (have the person in the room memorize the instruction book) is beside the point, as you can teach people to perform all sorts of algorithms without them needing to understand the result.
As many people have pointed out, Searle's argument begs the question by tacitly assuming that if anything about the room understands Chinese, it can only be the person within it.