Hospitals occasionally have angel of death doctors and nurses. Should we get rid of hospitals? There’s consistently a lack of any hard quantitative data about the harm the program causes but there are for the benefits. So for critics what’s left are anecdotal stories some of which are true some of which aren’t.
> In another case, the family of Alan Nichols said he died by euthanasia, with hearing loss listed as the sole criterion. The family reported it to police and health authorities- but neither saw cause to investigate further. The RCMP told the family that Nichols “met the criteria” for assisted death.
> But physicians who provide Maid caution that anecdotes of Canadians slipping through the cracks often ignore other critical details of their respective cases, which must include a “grievous and irremediable medical condition” and do not necessarily suggest a failure in the system.
It’s important to remember that the families of people who die will still look for someone to blame. It’s a very human reaction. I know someone who blames the doctor for causing or accelerating her husband’s terminal cancer diagnosis as well as blaming him for telling the husband he had a terminal diagnosis in the first place (i.e. sapped his energy and strength).
That’s not to say that there shouldn’t be adjustments to the program. But driving it through anecdotes instead of expertise and data is the wrong balance to strike.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/feb/25/canada-assiste...
You really want anecdotes in this case because they point to a system that is just getting rid of people for the wrong reasons. That's called insights.
But OK. So let’s presume we have anecdotes that show mistakes made in the program. Do we get rid of it? Hospitals and doctors and insurance companies make deadly mistakes too. Get rid of those as well? And what about the anecdotes of people who were greatly positively helped by euthanasia. Do we ignore their anecdotes? How do we weigh their anecdotes against the anecdotes of problems?
I may be thick but I’m failing to find the insights you’re claiming are there.
I must admit that people here tend to be against the death penalty but when it comes to killing people in difficult situations suddenly we need to be super flexible and innocents be damned
It’s worrying that you’re equating the death penalty and suicide when they’re very different things. Assisted suicide involves action by the person to end their life while the death penalty is the government taking that action. Very very very different things.
Even more worryingly that you’re outright discounting people killed by the death penalty as not innocent. Ignoring the obvious racial problems with black people being more likely to be sentenced that way since I don’t want to argue about sentencing disparity, the innocence project lets us estimate a lower bound on the amount of innocent people that had been killed before the invention of DNA (and even today after it’s part of the normal course of things). That number by the way I believe (but could be wrong) is higher by volume and percentage than the number of problematic deaths in assisted suicide. Care to rethink your priors about death penalty vs assisted suicide?
This is akin to "think of the children" excuse used to censor the web. But this time it actually kills people.
As for incentives, the estimate is that MAID reduces annual spending by ~100 million. The government spends 300B a year on healthcare. You’re not going to get out of this by killing your patients, not to mention that you need productive members in your economy to create a tax base in the first place. I think you have an incorrect analysis of the incentives at play here.