Re:The Codeless Code - Tales to make wiser programmers.
by drostie on Monday July 02, 2012 @06:04AM
(#4188173)
Agreed. What they inherit from koans appears to be merely the violence that the koans take for granted.
My favorite example of this is the story of Gutei's Finger:
I think the first thing anybody notices about this story is just the violence. When I told it to my brother he asked, "the lesson is, do not f--k with the Master?" But there is a deep set of Zen ideas -- lifting fingers which you do not have, and not getting attached to idiosyncrasy. Perhaps the boy even thought, "I should cut off the Master's finger," as he attained enlightenment.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Codeless Code - Tales to make wiser programmers.
by Estragon on Monday July 02, 2012 @08:25AM
(#4188530)
Violent koans aren't particularly common, they just stand out. However, they do reflect a fundamentally destructive aspect of spiritual practice, namely, that it undermines the conditioning behind cherished identities. The point of the story is that the boy was chasing after validation as a Zen master and had adopted the finger-raising ritual as a part of his identity as a competent Zen practitioner. When Gutei cut it off, he was removing a support for a cherished identity, and this was the basis for the boy's identity at that moment.
Re:The Codeless Code - Tales to make wiser programmers.
by Estragon on Monday July 02, 2012 @12:35PM
(#4189549)
s/basis for the boy's identity/led to the boy's enlightenment/. True as written, just a bit redundant, and not what I meant. :)
Re:The Codeless Code - Tales to make wiser programmers.
by orta on Monday July 02, 2012 @07:15AM
(#4188349)
I think, like almost everything, the Koans are a reflection on the society and the way of thinking at the time of writing. In what is now peacefuller times people would be aghast that someone would do that. I dug around through a few, and a lot of them feel a bit too meta for me, though I did find the Hello World Koan to be an interesting discussion on our flippancy with code: http://thecodelesscode.com/case/14