Re:Advancing Memory Safety
by germandiago on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:47AM
(#41857613)
I faced really strong criticism lately for criticizing (in the context of C++) a Safe C++ proposal that basically copies Rust into C++.
With all good and bad things this entails.
It seems there is a push from some people (that I hope it is not successful in its current shape, I personally find it a wrong approach) to just bifurcate C++ type system and standard library.
What I found a lot of is literally, intellectual dishonesty in some of the arguments to push in that direction.
Not that it is not a possible direction, but claims like: "there is no other way", "it is the only feasible solution", etc. without exploring other alternative, from which Swift/Hylo value semantics/subscripts (subscripts is basically controlled references for mutation without a full borrow checker) and adding compile-time enforced law of exclusivity semantics without a new type system are possible (and better, IMHO) alternatives... well, you can see the thread.
There seems to be a lot of obsession as "the only right way is the Rust way" and everything else is directly discardable by authors and some people supporting them.
With all good and bad things this entails.
It seems there is a push from some people (that I hope it is not successful in its current shape, I personally find it a wrong approach) to just bifurcate C++ type system and standard library.
More context here if you are curious: https://www.reddit.com/r/cpp/comments/1g41lhi/memory_safety_...
What I found a lot of is literally, intellectual dishonesty in some of the arguments to push in that direction.
Not that it is not a possible direction, but claims like: "there is no other way", "it is the only feasible solution", etc. without exploring other alternative, from which Swift/Hylo value semantics/subscripts (subscripts is basically controlled references for mutation without a full borrow checker) and adding compile-time enforced law of exclusivity semantics without a new type system are possible (and better, IMHO) alternatives... well, you can see the thread.
There seems to be a lot of obsession as "the only right way is the Rust way" and everything else is directly discardable by authors and some people supporting them.
I think there are a lot of strong feelings there.