Re:Unbluring web font icons: Response to GitHub's Octicons post
by wahnfrieden on Sunday July 01, 2012 @01:49PM
(#4185519)
How many typical users change their zoom level? I suspect not many. What % of users online have retina displays? I suspect a growing but still small number. So, it would still matter.
Re:Unbluring web font icons: Response to GitHub's Octicons post
by andreasvc on Sunday July 01, 2012 @03:10PM
(#4185780)
> How many typical users change their zoom level? I suspect not many.
How many people have less than perfect eyesight? I suspect very many.
Re:Unbluring web font icons: Response to GitHub's Octicons post
by bensummers on Sunday July 01, 2012 @01:52PM
(#4185528)
I suspect people using a Retina display are more than likely to be using a WebKit browser, so it's easy to make icons render nicely with just the font technique. This is my motivation for wanting to use a font for icons.
But to improve the quality on the desktop in other browsers, you can use a canvas element. And you don't lose anything over image icons when zooming.
End-users don't really care about "blurry" (i.e. anti-aliased) icons, since all their text is rendered the same way. They only care if the icons aren't legible.
Much better than trying to hack hard pixel edges, would be not to cram so much stuff into an icon in the first place. Examples:
- Instead of a dogeared document with lines on it (indicating text), just use a blank dogeared document
- Instead of a book+bookmark icon, just use the bookmark part, or just the book part, depending on what the icon is for
- Instead of slapping a "+" onto an existing icon (e.g. on top of a book with a bookmark, to indicate "new repository" on Github), just use a "+" icon by itself, and ensure the context makes it clear that we're talking about a repository
GitHub tried to cram way too much information into a lot of their icons, and it's basically useless IMHO. Icons shouldn't be self-contained complex symbol languages; they should be simple and depend on context for full meaning. They're not sentences, they're signposts.