http://atari.com/arcade/arcade/centipede
It's really difficult, and I think that it might have been partially designed to suck down quarters. The best Atari game is this:
...yeah it looks like crap, but he crammed it into 4K, and at the time there was literally nothing like it in the world.
Most people say this is the best Atari game:
http://www.atari.com/arcade/arcade/yars-revenge
...I still remember the rather lengthy comic book that came with the cartridge explaining the plight of the yars in their struggle against the armored cannon, or whatever.
ED: found the comic. I guess it's not that long:
http://www.atariage.com/comics/comic_thumbs.html?MagazineID=...
what
Well check out tempest and Super Locomotive (which hardly anyone else remembers). And Q*Bert. And Gorf.
Try to find an actual historic arcade. The games make more sense in context. In particular, Tempest has been redone in a dozen forms, but without the original spinner controller it's just not the same.
(QBert, on the other hand, is just fine in emulation.)
In the Northeast you can go to Funspot:
http://www.classicarcademuseum.org/
It's got the flavor of the real thing. Takes me back to the old days.
To that list I'd add Spy Hunter (don't want to think how many quarters I sank into this without ever getting very far) and Gaplus (my favorite of the Galaxion spin-offs).
Robotron:2084.
Gravitar.
Bosconian.
Red Baron and Battlezone.
Many, many quarters spent.
What amazes me is that you can still find Galaga in arcades today. If, of course, you can find arcades at all.