Philip Greenspun's Economy Recovery Plan

Re:Philip Greenspun's Economy Recovery Plan by natrius on Saturday January 03, 2009 @04:28AM (#418269)

"I guess I'm asking for evidence of school districts that are both well-funded and well-managed, using (for instance) the Charity Navigator definition of well-managed (admin and fundraising costs kept to under N% of program expenditures)."

That criterion has the same problem with education as it does with charitable organizations: it decouples money spent from results achieved. Maybe the answer to more effective schools and charitable organizations is better administrators who can only be recruited with competitive salaries. If that's the case, using that criterion would force schools and charitable organizations to hire less capable administrators in order to get enough funding.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Philip Greenspun's Economy Recovery Plan by tptacek on Saturday January 03, 2009 @01:46PM (#418549)

I get that "money spent" does not equal "results achieved". But: in many of the worst cases where money hasn't equalled results, the cause has been money misspent on administration: bloated staff, unreasonable compensation, new buildings. So while the Charity Navigator definition may not be perfect, it's a very solid heuristic. For instance, it detects the DC school system.

[ Parent | on HN ]