Re:First Greenhouse Gas Plumes Detected with NASA-Designed I...
by blackeyeblitzar on Saturday October 12, 2024 @10:48PM
(#41824774)
> You are getting a well-deserved correction to your ignorance of political forces that might result from perceived threats to the oil and gas industry.
What I am getting from your comment is an ad hominem attack just because I asked for evidence around claims that I can only assume were false. Instead of admitting they were false, you’re calling me “ignorant”. Nice.
Re:First Greenhouse Gas Plumes Detected with NASA-Designed I...
by cwalv on Sunday October 13, 2024 @12:00AM
(#41825058)
Nothing wrong with ignorance .. asking for a source, as you did, is implicitly saying you recognize that you may be ignorant. The only shameful ignorance is ignorance of ignorance.
That said, I assumed the "You are getting a well-deserved correction" part you're replying to had a typo, or was referring to some other post. I didn't parse it the same way. To me, if a correction of ignorance is "well deserved," that's a vague compliment.
Re:First Greenhouse Gas Plumes Detected with NASA-Designed I...
by bloomingeek on Sunday October 13, 2024 @12:54AM
(#41825265)
When someone points to an area of my ignorance, I research the hell out of it to become educated on the matter. If I were to become offended by this being pointed out, I would have succumbed to stupidity.
I want to comment on a separate thing, about responsibility for the measurement, that’s in your second paragraph.
Developing the spectroscopic measurement of methane from space took a lot of time and engineering skill. (I happened to observe some of this work as part of $dayjob.) In the US, the responsibility for developing novel space measurement technology has historically gone to NASA.
It is proven in space (raised to “TRL 9” in the jargon) by NASA, and then transitioned to other sectors, like NOAA or USGS, for operational use. The prioritization and maturation is very well developed at this point.
Part of the reason it rests with NASA is that systems for spectroscopic measurement of gases (in this example) are also used for other space missions, e.g. planetary and astrophysics. For instance, some of the team of this methane instrument overlaps with the MISE team that will use spectroscopy for Europa https://europa.nasa.gov/spacecraft/instruments/mise/). Besides sharing personnel and knowledge, I believe some of the sensor hardware for MISE and for that in OP was fabricated at the same facility.