Re:DuckStation
by perching_aix on Saturday October 12, 2024 @05:01PM
(#41822534)
I think that's specifically what they refer to by open source "having become" "a caricature of its ideas".
FSF and OSI have been critical of "source available" licenses for decades, so if open source is a caricature now, it always has been.
Re:DuckStation
by perching_aix on Saturday October 12, 2024 @05:29PM
(#41822822)
I'd personally agree with that (hence my quotes around the having become part), although I'm not nearly caught up with the lore enough to know whether equating open source with the FSF and OSI is fair. Also can't vouch for the thread starter's opinion of course.
The only thing I have learned here is that apparently software licensing is very difficult and
Makes me wonder what the general statistics are on individuals ignoring licensing entirely.
Time to go make the ultimate SPDX-License-Identifier with an OR clause between every single entry.
Specifically, it violates freedom 3 of the FSF definition (redistribute changes), and section 3 of the OSI definition (Derived Works). This freedom is at the core of what FOSS is.
And that's before the violation of freedom 0, "The freedom to run the program as you wish, for any purpose" of the non commercial licenses.