Re:JavaScript Structs
by Swalden123 on Friday October 11, 2024 @09:25AM
(#41809296)
Classes are still built around prototype inheritance, there are some differences, however they are still an easier to use api on top.
Re:JavaScript Structs
by LegionMammal978 on Friday October 11, 2024 @11:05AM
(#41810129)
Yeah, iirc private properties (added in ES2022) are currently the only part of ES6 classes that can neither be created nor accessed using prototype-based code, to the consternation of some people when they were added. Of course, provate properties can still be readily emulated with a WeakMap in a function scope.
Using JS/TS in a functional style doesn’t mean using prototypes or function binding or anything. I’m not sure how you inferred that from the comment you’re replying to…it just means using plain objects (TypeScript even, a little awkwardly, lets you express ADTs) and plain functions, perhaps with the module system to organize them.
My point was rather that a functional style with plain old data was always preferable, the "stink" was that early TS versions _favored_ non-functional OO style that suited the TS type system at a time when most modern JS code already had a functional approach, so you ended up writing non-idiomatic JS because the TS type system wouldn't handle idiomatic code (this also contributed to a lingering distrust in TypeScript that persists to this day despite the upgrades to the typing system).
Personally I prefer neither prototypal or classes, 90% of the time you just want the interfaces, unions or inferred types and the few places where you actually want inheritance and/or object methods you really are just better off with a factory method that then creates a literal that is used or suits an interface.
The Crockford crowd would like us to live in a world of ES5 as if that's some kind of badge of pride, while justifying it with a warcry of "functional", while breaking the preconceptions of functional programming all throughout.