Re:Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
by jshen on Friday June 29, 2012 @09:15PM
(#4180051)
I'm absolutely 100% certain that the analysis you speak of is an educated guess at best.
I think it is very easy to imagine irreparable harm being done.
Re:Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
by taligent on Friday June 29, 2012 @08:28PM
(#4179923)
In the words of the court, "The Court finds that the full extent of these losses would likely be unascertainable, difficult to calculate, and irreparable."
And I fully agree that the finance department would be able to calculate the expected profit per customer for today's products. But what about tomorrow's ? And the next year ?
Apple locks in the user at multiple points: apps, movies, TV shows, books, accessories etc.
Re:Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
by jmduke on Friday June 29, 2012 @10:14PM
(#4180196)
You're using circular logic. "The court finds theory of irreparable harm to be plausible because the court finds that the full extent of these losses would be irreparable."
OP's entire argument is that the court's finding is incorrect and that's why its a victory for Apple's lawyers -- I think you're severely underestimating the forecasting techniques used, especially in a company as competent as Apple.
Re:Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
by Tloewald on Saturday June 30, 2012 @12:36AM
(#4180615)
The OP did not address this argument, but merely asserted that no irreparable harm would be done because you could simply pay damages. The court has said that calculating damages is impossible.
It doesn't seem to me that incalculable implies irreparable but it's certainly a defensible position.
Re:Apple granted preliminary sales ban of Galaxy Nexus
by enraged_camel on Friday June 29, 2012 @09:17PM
(#4180057)
There is no such "technique". They can make educated guesses, but that's about it.
There's a technique pretty much every company that knows what's it doing applies to figure out exactly what you mentioned and it's called downstream impact analysis.
I'm absolutely 100% certain if you're an executive at Apple and you ask your finance department what the downstream impact is of an iPhone sale the finance department will come back with numbers for the profit variance when the customer wasn't already a customer, when they already were and a bunch of other scenarios.